Mally Beauty Evercolor Starlight Waterproof Liner
Best Liner Around!
I love this liner; it goes on so nicely and stays put. I apply once in the morning and it's still there 10 (or more) hours later when I get home from work. I can't say that for any other liner I've tried....and I've tried a lot! I use a sharpener I've had for a long time to sharpen this liner and haven't had any problem getting it sharp. I'm hooked and hope this one is never discontinued.
Can't keep it sharp
I loved this eyeliner when I first got it - it goes on so easily! But the point wore down quickly and I could not get another point when I sharpened it. I kept at it and was down to a nub before I knew it. The pencil is very expensive for what little product you end up with.
Don't worry about finding the correct sharpener
I have had 2 of these and neither one will crank up to expose more product. When it happened with the first one, it was more than 30 days so I couldn't return it, but I thought it was just a fluke. Then I got another one as part of a set, and the same thing happened. Two out of 2 did not work.
I like it otherwise. It is NOT bullet proof, but lasted better than most.
Got half a stick of eye liner
I wanted to like this eye liner after watching the demo's on QVC. Just received this today and thought it was very small. Turns out it was broke in half (not worth paying to have it shipped back), However; I was still able to use it and was not impressed at all. Just once I would love to order something that does what they say it does. It does not go on the inner eyelids nor does it stay on.
Not only is this not waterproof but it wipes off with no water at all.
Love Mally products!!
I absolutely love Mally eye products. I believe that she makes the best in the market. I only have one suggestion. I realize that QVC has a policy of allowing customers to return merchandise that they decide they don't want for whatever reason. I've just noticed that sometimes when I order the eyeliner that is retractable, sometimes it is already extended as far as it will go so it had to have been used and returned. I can't believe people would use a product like that and return it, but I guess there are some people that would return anything. Some of these products make your eyes itch also.
My suggestion is that you have a site for returned eye merchandise and sell it as such at a reduced price. That way, we could avoid buying already used eye makeup which is very unsanitary. Just had to make that suggestion. Overall love her makeup..
Eye brow liner
Received sooner than expected,great product,will purchase again,
Wanted to love it
but ... it's not waterproof or smudgeproof AT ALL. In fact, I've used much less expensive drug store brands that lasted longer. Not impressed.
I ordered the set of 5 In The Buff....liners. i have never purchased liners other than ones i find at the local stores here. i knew mallys things were the best i'd found so i got those....as they are the colors i use all the time. .......and am i glad i did. they go on so effortlessly and my eye make up has never looked so good. this stuff stays just like Mallys claims they do. the colors i chose are gorgeous! i can use all of them with different combinations. get them. the people that buy these want beautiful rich color that's easy to apply and stays till you take it off! and make your eyes look amazingly beautiful..... :) not kidding. i love them. THank you Mally! and thanks QVC for the great deals on great products.
Don't Ever Stop Making Lucky Penny!
Lucky Penny is the most fabulous eyeliner color EVER. Please do not stop making it. I buy 3 at a time because I keep thinking it will disappear from your inventory. I use a very fine line of a darker color as close to the eyelashes as I can get and then overlay it with Lucky Penny. I am brunette and have hazel eyes. This gives my eyes a luminous look. Love it.
worst eyeliner ever
received this pencil in a Test Tube kit. I am always on the look out for a good eyeliner pencil. I thought this might be it until I actually began using it. It does glide on very smooth but it is not waterproof or smudgeproof nor can it be used to draw on a fine line. You can forget about using it once it needs to be sharpened. It doesn't fit in any of my sharpeners and you just end up wasting most of the pencil trying to get that fine point. good thing I didn't pay full price plus shipping for something as bad as this. Maybe her automatic pencils work better but this is a waste of time and money. Into the trash it goes.
Love these liners and use every day. I was always a Lancome liner gal because of the colors and texture of the liners, but got tired of having raccoon eyes by the end of the day and having to clean off and reapply before going out. These were the first Mally items I tried and I've been very impressed with how they apply so smoothly and "stay put" as promoted. My only complaint is I go through them very quickly. I have to sharpen the liner after every other application. I would ask Mally to please make these pencils twice the length. I would pay extra for the longer pencil so I didn't have to order them so frequently. That said, these are fabulous and the only liners I use anymore.