Mally Beauty Evercolor Starlight Waterproof Liner
this lasts all day on the upper eyelid but disappears on the lower one. Also not that easy to "smudge".
A WHITE Liner, PLEASE
This Liner is the absolute BEST ever...it will stay forever until you actually remove it with a makeup remover (ie Purity or Mally's) MALLY, WE NEED A WHITE WATERPROOF LINER FOR THE INNER EYE RIMS....PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!
One of my all-time favorites!
This Mally eyeliner is great. It's creamy enough to apply smoothly, smudges beautifully, and once it's set it really stays on all day. (I recommend using a good eyelid primer to help it stay put.) I purchased the color called Black Cherry - it's my absolute favorite color I've ever used; I like it so much I always get two at a time.
Love Caribbean Sea
I love the color of this eyeliner! My all time favorite! My daughter loves the Midnight black. However, these loves of ours cause our eyes to itch badly! I thought Mally made her cosmetics hypoallergenic.??? If not, Mally, please fix the eyeliners we love so much so we can continue to wear them!!!!
The BEST waterproof eyeliner out there!
I have found this eyeliner to be THE BEST in every way that is important to me: great colors, applies very smoothly with as thick or as thin a line as I want, smudges to perfection, doesn't budge after about a minute tops, color stays true all day and evening, is a good value for the price, and causes no allergic reaction. I have found Mally's other waterproof eyeliners to be every bit as good but buy this one because of the particular shade of the two colors I wear all the time. I wouldn't wear any other!
This is the second one we purchased. It goes on so smooth and easy and lasts until you remove it. There are so many colors to choose from and the price is pretty reasonable.
Real Let Down
I have issues with makeup creasing easily and Mally swore this eyeline wouldn't budge. I promise you it budges and it budges quickly. I returned it.
A bit disappointed
Liners smudged, but I like them so I carry q-tips!
Best eyeliner !
Happy to see this eyeliner back in stock. Ordered 2 midnight and tried the Gunmetal. Gunmetal is really nice as is the midnight. Since it's at the event $ too... I'm going to order 2 more gunmetal and will try the Caribbean teal. I have blue eyes and the midnight on upper eye lid with gunmetal lined on lower eyelid looks fantastic. AND, they DO last all day.
This was my FIRST Mally product and... I am so disappointed!! It is NOT waterproof and it smudges!!! and.. it is very rough on the eyelid since it is necessary to go over several times in order to get some color (I order the black!) I did return it but the ordeal cost me over $11. in shipping (shipping and return) I cannot believe that other persons have found this product acceptable !!
Excellent! Love, Love, Love!
Mally please do not stop making this eye line. It is out of this world. It last forever and goes on so smooth. Plus the price is right. I have turned on all my friends to this eye Liner. Keep it coming! I wish this was on auto-delivery. I love the color midnight---it's just the perfect color. Thank you Mally.
I keep trying for a better eyeliner! This works well so I guess I am the problem. I just can't seem to get a straight line. This is the best that I have tried.