Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 258
Rated 1 out of 5 by Fudamo Not quite..
This pencil has a few flaws. First the color is not so bullet proof and second when you have used up the point of the pencil, you can not scroll up more color. After just a few uses, the pencil is finished. Not worth the price until a better way to dispense the color.
Rated 5 out of 5 by DING Beautiful color but What happened?
My daughter and I love the dark chocolate liner, but when I tried to order one it was not available. What happened? That color is oh so beautiful and is a nice switch from wearing black. Please bring the color back
Rated 5 out of 5 by Fooney Bless you Mally!! Perfect for me!
I have been looking for this color eyeliner for - well it seems like forever. I was down to the nub of my previous pencil and injuring my eyelid with the wood when applying it. Thank you, thank you, Mally for making this perfect color. You have literally saved my eyelids. I liked this so well I ordered several other colors. Staying power is great and you really can get close to the edge of the lid and not cry it off. Now I am thinking about ordering another of this Caribbean blue/green color. I love it and you know what happens when you fall in love with a product - sure as taxes they will discontinue it. I am not going to hurt my eyes again so I guess I had better order a spare or two.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Cardmaker63 Great, but where's the sharpener?!!
I decided to buy the espresso as I get older, the black looks way to harsh on me!! I LOVE the color, most fab !! Problem: How do I sharpen it?! Mally's lash liner, the thin line I have always used, DOES come with a sharpener!! But, that sharpener is too small to get this one into!! I was a tad bit surprised when I realized this, so will use a regular pencil sharpener! But, it DOES stay on really well! Very happy with THAT part of it! Thanks Mally & Q !
Rated 1 out of 5 by lisakoto Not Bulletproof
I like how easy the liner goes on. But after a few hours I need to reapply. This product is not bulletproof as Mally advertised. Very disappointed.
Rated 4 out of 5 by gloriags Love the ease of applying the eyeliner
It is not 'bullet' proof but it is a very nice eyeliner that goes on smoothly and easily.
Rated 5 out of 5 by PaddiePea Life liner
This by far is the best eye liner I have ever owned. This eye liner will be the only thing I use from now on. It goes on so smooth and stays put without smudging. It's water proof but comes off nicely with my remover.
Rated 4 out of 5 Great product but not bulletproof.
This is really a great pencil, slides on easily, the milk chocolate is the best brown under the sun. But this is not bulletproof....but nothing is.
Rated 5 out of 5 by 2255 Best on the market!
Best eye liner out there. Stays on, is so beautiful, just glildes on your eye lids.
Please sell "lucky Penny" in sets of 5 (of that color). I use it every day and would looove to have 5 of lucky penny in my cabinet.
Rated 1 out of 5 by spence82 Bullet Proof?
Were is the bullet proof eyeliner? Very disappointed.
Rated 5 out of 5 by CHDaley4 Goes On Like BUTTAH!
Seriously! Like a slim stick of butter! Goes on PERFECTLY, no having to 'pull' your eyes! And at 50 , I do NOT want to be tugging on my eyes! Love this, ordering more colors!! ;-D
Rated 5 out of 5 by BICHONMAMA Love Mally
Beautiful color.....goes on smoothly......stays till I take it off!