Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 274
Rated 5 out of 5 by twin2016 LOVE!
This is the best eyeliner pencil I have ever purchased! I have extremely sensitive eyes and have no issues with this brand. I do wish however that they would bring back all the colors and keep them available to purchase. If I could rate this * I would! Thank you Mally for such a great product.....loyal customer
Rated 5 out of 5 by djpless STOCK THE BROWN SHADES
love the eye liner but you DONT keep them stocked ..need the brown shades KONA AND ESPRESSO ....why do you get people to like the products and then we cant reorder... I gave the liner a 5 star but I give you a 2 for no stock !!!!! PLEASE PLEASE stock these
Rated 5 out of 5 by nitereader Please Bring Back Smoky Taupe
Great eyeliner. But please bring back the smoky taupe. Thanks.
Rated 4 out of 5 by ZoieMae Best eyeliner
I love Mally's eyeliner, but I don't love the fact that my favorites are so often out of stock! Please restock the sailor and cobalt!
Rated 1 out of 5 by aroonie Expensive Product
After I used up the part showing, the other wouldn't roll up. This was a very expensive product--1/4 inch for $18. I would not recommend it for anyone.
Rated 5 out of 5 by mlal Mally Evercolor Starlight Waterproof Liner
This liner deserves five stars! I have been using them for YEARS and they do stay on til you take them off. I just WISH QVC would provide more colors that she had in kits in the past such as Chocolate Diamond, that one was my favorite. Also please put Lucky Penny back in stock!!!!!!
I have tried all others liners and this one glides on perfectly and stays on. Great product.
Please keep colors in stock and add more!
Rated 5 out of 5 by LMS2010 Best I've ever used
These eyeliners live up to their description - the color doesn't come off under my eyes during the day and lasts until I wash off my makeup at night. I've tried so many other brands from QVC and Nordstrom, and these really are the best! Please keep them in stock and offer more 3 packs!
Rated 1 out of 5 by PatLe Crumbles
What speedy delivery! That was the only plus regarding this item. As soon as I took the protective little lid off and touched the tip SLIGHTLY it broke off, so I had to sharpen it right away even before using it. After sharpening (which I did VERY carefully and not to a sharp point) I went to apply it to my lid and it totally crumbled. After all the good reviews I read, I thought this would be an awesome product, and couldn't wait to get it and use it, but for me, this is totally unusable. I am returning and will not buy another Mally product. Ever.