Rated 3.7 out of 5 by 976
Rated 2 out of 5 by DIAinCA Don't Buy Into the Hype
I loved the idea that this mascara would look like I am wearing eyeliner, but it does no such thing. You ARE able to get all the way to the base of the lash, but it does not look like eyeliner. I don't get the "primer" part either. My mascara doesn't wear any differently with or without it Tightline. Sorry, but it is going back.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Gashopper Excellent for the hooded eyes
I am 48 and have been struggling to find a mascara that does not weigh my eyes down and this BY FAR looks so natural and does not give my eye a heavy look. LOVE IT!!!!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by LadyLove I LOVE IT!
I'm not one that wears a ton of makeup though I buy a ton. This product gives me just the right amount of mascara to give my tiny lashes a natural and not so made up look. If I get close enough to my lash line it gives me the illusion of wearing an eyeliner in which I still struggle with applying eyeliner.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Lisachristian Gets every lash
I like the tiny brush. It gets all the lashes. I thought I was getting the mascara with it. I didn't order the right one. Maybe next time. Works pretty good on its own.
Rated 2 out of 5 by sedona Bends
The one nice thing about this is it does separate the lashes and doesn't make them crimp. The negative is it's very easy to bend the tip. You have to be really careful putting it back.
Rated 2 out of 5 by LisaPflip Nothing special
The small brush was good, however, the product was nothing special. I didn't notice anything making my lashes "amazing" other than the tiny brush getting in close. The wand is bigger than the tube holding the product, and the product wore off easily throughout the day.
Rated 1 out of 5 by stylefan I wanted to love this
Because Jamie is so adorable, committed to making us beautiful, and her company is cruelty free. But this mascara is not good. The wand is so coated with product that you can't tightline without getting the mascara in your eye. The mascara clumps terribly. I put it on and took it off three times to "try again" and finally just used it as mascara. It still clumped.
Rated 1 out of 5 by abc542 Not Good
I bought this mainly because they said it will give you the look of eyeliner on your lashes. This absolutely does not give you the look of eyeliner, nor is it a good lash primer or mascara either. I usually like IT cosmetics, but this Tightline is absolute trash.
Rated 5 out of 5 by AnnchensIL I love IT!!!!!
This is the best lash primer ever!!! my second order. I love it and share with family.
they love it too. Really improves the quality of your lashes. I would recommend to anyone who wants fuller lashes.
Rated 4 out of 5 by mk12 Good Product.
What makes this so great is the size of the brush. I am like totally blind ( lol not really but i do have really bad vision) and this little wand helps so much to get down to the roots of the lashes without me worrying about hitting my eyes. As far as the look of having eye liner on with it, not so much. It does give the effect of great eyelashes with out the extra heavy product. I even took a shower with it and not a huge raccoon face like with most mascaras. I gave 4 stars because the claim of having the look with eyeliner was just not there for me. With that being said it is still a great mascara and for the price of 24.00 for 2 of them, you will not go wrong.
Rated 5 out of 5 by I_Like_Sparkles Amazing way to tight line
I have always heard about tight lining but never really knew how to do it. Plus I wear gas permeable contact lens and for some reason putting eye liner on my waterline causes my contact lens to fog up.
I had watched some YouTube make up gurus who used this product and saw such a noticeable difference after they applied this mascara/primer. The brush wand is so very long and skinny. I've never seen a wand do long and skinny. But as the makeup gurus said, the mascara really gets to the base of the lashes and just using a little bit made a BIG difference on my eyes, just like theirs! It's so crazy how my eyes look tight lined but it's just the base of my eyelashes that are really dark, so it doesn't affect my contact lens!
So I finished my makeup and went to work and my coworker noticed and said that my eye make up was really nice. I love this stuff! I am hooked. I'm going to buy it here on QVC because the savings are WONDERFUL. The whole IT cosmetics line has been transforming. (WHERE WERE YOU ALL MY LIFE???)
Rated 3 out of 5 by craftylisa Too small
I gave 3 stars because it's a wonderful product , and does what it claims, however if the container worked the opposite , it would be worth the cost. What I mean is, the larger part of the container isn't the product which is highly disappointing. It doesn't last long.