Rated 3.7 out of 5 by 893
Rated 2 out of 5 by Photogl58 Would be perfect IF...
I have small eyes with thin, short lashes so brands with big brushes are difficult to use. I love the small brush on this product, it was extremely easy to use on my eyes, and I loved that I could roll it above my lashline for a liner effect (thanks to the small brush). The mascara went on very nice, my lashes looked great, no clumps, looked very natural. HOWEVER, the mascara is incredibly difficult to remove, and I don't think I should have to spend more money buying any specialty makeup remover products. Also, the product doesn't last long. The tube seems to be smaller to go with the smaller brush. Smaller tube equals less product.
Make this a full size tube with mascara that doesn't need to be chisled off, and I'd probably buy it again.
Rated 2 out of 5 by grace1958 what a waste of money
don't buy this. I still had to use other mascara to even look like I had any on.
Rated 2 out of 5 by gwenj Makes My Lashes Stiff and Brittle
I ordered the regular formula, not the waterproof and it is unbelievably hard to remove, even with eye makeup remover. While this product's skinny brush does find every lash, the formula cannot be good for one's lashes. After applying one or two coats, my eyelashes feel like cement -- so brittle and stiff, that it's hardly worth putting on. I can get similar results just by using other mascara. Sorry, but I didn't get the eyeliner effect of this product. I do have other IT Cosmetic products that I use and love though.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Turquoise3 Not Worth the Price
I bought this thinking that the people who said it flaked and came off easily just had bad luck with it or rubbed their eyes....wrong. It does flake. I like the CoverGirl Lash Blast mascara because the brushes do the same job without the flaking. If I'm paying a lot for a high-end brand, I don't want it to perform less than drugstore brands. I returned it after giving it three tries. Really hope they improve the formula. The tiny brush is such a great idea, but they need to make the mascara better and the wand more sturdy before I try it again.
Rated 1 out of 5 by adorable doris Terrible
This product is completely useless I didnt even want to give it one star
Rated 4 out of 5 by itgirl69 Finally,a mascara keeper!!
I love this mascara. Goes on easily, no clumps. Does what it is supposed to. Only four stars because there doesn't seem to be much in the tube. I won't use another mascara again!!!
Rated 1 out of 5 by flallon1 worse purchase ever
I will never purchase this item again,..it bends after using a few times, very disappointed ,...but she sure make's it seem terrific on tv doesn't she!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by 3659 Miracle Worker
I am 55 and not in the greatest health. My lashes were sparse, short and not long enough to even curl. I tried the tightline primer for about a month and got up one day and realized my lashes are growing and filling in. I only used the primer without any other mascara. I am beyond thrilled, I have enough lashes to be visible and curled.
Rated 5 out of 5 love this!!
I am in my 60's with long blonde lashes and this mascara is the absolute best. I have never been able to color my lashes so close to my lid. So easy and no clumps. I don't even have to bother with a liner. Makes life a bit easier!!
Rated 1 out of 5 by Lots of Fun IT Cosmetics TIGHTLINE Full Lash Black Mascara Pri
I have not found it as easy to use as seen on TV. I am trying to use per the directions, but cannot get the results shown on TV. This may be a user error, but I doubt it. I probably will be returning, and of course will have to pay the return fee. I will have to determine if it is worth the S&H return or just "pitch it". If I were in charge, I would not expect customers to pay for the return, as the customer would have already paid S&H on the original order.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Farrah This is just ok
The idea of this product would be great if it worked the way they say it does. For me, It tends to leave a mess on my eyelids. It works wonders for my lower lashes so I decided to keep it…although the price is very high. I believe that this product would probably do wonders for people with straight lashes. Overall, I love IT Cosmetics and will give everything in the line a try.