Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 22
Rated 2 out of 5 by jmdf Disappointed
The colors are beautiful but the shadows came dried out. It truly was a waste of money!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Lilbit0401 Amazing!!!
Just received these today and I wore the bronze/champagne and it is beautiful!!! They're all very pretty just from the swatches I did on my arm I can't wait to try all of them and even mix some of the shadows together to get a more dramatic look!! The liner and shadows are very creamy. In so glad I purchased these!!!!!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by PJ4 Best Liner/Shadow Ever
I love these tarte Liner/Shadow sticks. They are duel ended with the crayon on one end and powder on the other. And made from good for you ingredients.
Rated 3 out of 5 by unaughtything Not great but nice...
So I bought these mostly as something easy for travel. I gave 3 stars because the description says cream shadow and they are actually powder, 2 shades are so similar it is hard to tell them apart and lastly the black eyeliner on 1 of mine was dried out and doesn't work. These do however perform fairly well with the use of an eyelid primer. Handy since they are double ended. Kept because they are good for travel and 2 of the colors I do like , very versatile.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Makedonka Perfect for quick smokey
I have not had bad experiences with these - nothing had dried out; I managed to actually use up one of the liners.
The way these work for me is I apply primer first, then swipe the shadow using the sponge-y tip over the entire lid going lil bit into the crease (sometimes I mix the light shade and apply it in the middle of the lid only - otherwise the light ones to me are "under a brow" type color), and finish with lining up water line on the top eye lid + entire outside (top lid only, again) = the result is gorgeous smokey day look. The liners look thick but they apply wonderfully - smudged blurred line that compliments the shadow.
The best part - takes 5 mins in the morning, which is why I am addicted to these. You have no way of messing up! :) The final product is professional look in a very short time.
Rated 5 out of 5 by laura tay Great great great
Love these colors for the lids and eyeliner.
Lasts all day!
Rated 4 out of 5 by dexters mom It's growing on me
I was a little hesitant to order this product due to the negative reviews, I am glad that I took the chance....I like it. Took a little getting used to as the shadow color itself is in the top and that just seems a little strange. I like the simplicity of the product and that you just don't have to think to much about making everything match ~ it's done for you.
The eyeliner itself does seem a little on the dry side compared to other Tarte eyeliners but this one is just different and I'm okay with that. I would like to see more "sets" in different colors ~ maybe brown, green, purple.
Rated 1 out of 5 by angeldiva Shadow runs dry after one use
What a joke. First of all, box doesn't come with any instructions. Not that you really need them, but if your shadow runs dry after the first use, you may wonder, am I doing something wrong. Well you're not. Its just a very bad product. Liner is good but shadow is limited.