Rated 3.8 out of 5 by 222
Rated 1 out of 5 by EGSuzie I had such high hopes
I made the mistake of buying a six pack of these mascaras when they were on a special offer, and unfortunately, I ended up feeling extraordinarily disappointed in this product. It is clumpy and messy on first use and it only gets worse day by day. Not to mention having to clean up around the lash line on upper and lower lids each time I apply it, no matter how careful I try to be! I finally admitted defeat and disgust and threw away the remaining 3 vials of mascara...most of it would have ended up on QTips in the trash bin anyway.
Rated 1 out of 5 by teacher813 The Worse
I've been a huge Malloy fan for years. However, this product is clumpy and definitely not user friendly. I have tossed them all in the garbage.
Rated 1 out of 5 by ppennsy Definite Change In Formula
I had used this mascara for years...it was the very best mascara I had ever used and I've used them all even the very high end mascaras. I recommended it to everyone and a lot of them became devoted Mally customers because of this product but here has been a definite change in the formula in the last couple of years and there is no way this can still be a best seller. It now clumps, flakes, is not buildable....I could go on and on. I have tried several tubes thinking I got a bad batch but they were all the same. I have submitted 5 e-mails on Mally's website over the past several months in reference to the change in formula but have never received a response from Mally or her representatives. Does anyone at the company read the e-mails that are submitted. Do QVC representatives or Mally read these reviews? If you do, you would surely see that many customers know there has been a change to this mascara and therefore are no longer purchasing it. It doesn't make sense. QVC tell Mally to go back to the original or just quit selling it altogether.
Rated 5 out of 5 by LanieGail BEST Mascara Ever
I'm a mascara nut. I love mascara and I am constantly buying new mascaras. I had gotten a Mally make-up assortment about a year ago and I loved the mascara and now I'm hooked. It's not hard on your lashes and it doesn't smudge. It lengthens the lashes, it's really awesome.
Rated 1 out of 5 by CeveB Bummed
I have used Mally Volumizing Mascara for at least 5 years now and swore by it. Loved the way it made my lashes look. The last two tubes I've received have been awful....comes out clumpy, goes on clumpy, and makes my lashes look spiky. I was somewhat relieved to read other reviews saying the same thing. Not sure if / why the formula has changed, but it's definitely not a change for the better. I'm really bummed that I have to go through looking for a new mascara.....
Rated 1 out of 5 by nicki12 WHAT IS GOING ON WITH THIS COMPANY ANYMORE?!
this USED to be my HOLY GRAIL mascara....could not live without it. i have been using it for YEARS. lately, it has been an absolute NIGHTMARE to apply. a total goopy mess as other have stated. it takes at least 2 cotton swabs PER EYE to clean up my EYELIDS after applying this to my LASHES....it's THAT messy! i know mally's company has undergone some changes financially recently but it appears that it has left many casualties in it's path...such as really unhappy and heartbroken LOYAL customers like myself. the cancellation concealer is gone and i just found out the other day that my HOLY GRAIL ever color starlight liner in my GO TO shade of royal plum has also been discounted. are you kidding me?! it was one of the first shades she ever had in those eyeliners. i am so disheartened by the changes to her products and her company. i'm so loyal that i can't imagine going elsewhere so PLEASE don't make me have to. GO BACK TO THE OLD FORMULA! GO BACK TO ALL THE 5 STAR PRODUCTS THAT YOUR CUSTOMERS LOVE(D) SO MUCH! PLEASE MALLY! if it ain't broke....:(
Rated 1 out of 5 by amyb What Have You Done To The Best Mascara Ever?!!
If you read my review under the duo set of these mascaras from 2010, you'd see how I used to feel about this mascara, which USED TO BE...PERFECTION! It used to be exactly as Mally would sell it..."bullet proof, didn't come off until you took it off, no racoon eyes ever!, etc"...now it is exactly none of those things, but the exact opposite. I know (we all know) Mally's company underwent some financial woes in recent years and now all the (award-winning, BEST) products seem to either be going away (Cancellation Concealer...please come back!!) or being changed. (Meanwhile marketing some "new and improved" other versions.)
I thought it was just one bad mascara, until it happened a second time, I came online and found other women lamenting the very same thing on the Q boards and in the reviews...this mascara, SADLY, now is gloppy, doesn't go on smooth, easy and dry like before, doesn't stay like it used to, I ALWAYS have racoon eyes now every day, but then when I actually go to take it off it takes forever to get off, and smears like sticky TAR under my eyes!! Takes remover and several washes and pulling on my eyes to clean them. :((( I've used this mascara for as long as Mally has been on QVC, and loved it...it was the best I'd ever ever used. Now I'm in search of a new best...I've gotten some recommendations I won't mention here, as you won't post my review...
PLEASE QVC, PLEASE MALLY...Whatever you need to do, bring us back the original mascara (and concealer) ....they were both truly 10 steps above any and all brands (I'd tried many of the famous brands) out there....it's a shame to have ruined them. :( FIX IT!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Salongirl Simply the best..
Love this mascara stays on all day doesn't feel crispy.. Length volume.. U get it all from this!