Rated 4.2 out of 5 by 66
Rated 5 out of 5 by heavenlyB 10 + STARS
This eyeliner has it all....I NEED more of my Lucky Penny ASAP, PLEASEEEEE!!!! Please sell a duo of lucky penny,or in a single pencil purchase of lucky penny...I have been using these eyeliners (many colors) for years....LOVE, LOVE, LOVEEEEEEEE!!!!!!
LUCKY PENNY IS MY FAVORITE FOR MY UNDER EYE LINER.
Massachusetts...65 yr. old nana/diva (P.S. The staying power is sincerely MAGNIFICENT .....other eyeliners (and I have tried many) CANNOT compare to Mally's). I would highly recommend this product to all my friends and have done so...my bestie has ordered many in the past per my suggestion and loves them.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Lexibug Perfection!
I love these eyeliners and will wear nothing else but these. They stay on until you take it off just like Mally says. I love the caribbean sea color and wear it more than any other. I give away a lot of colors to family and friends when they come to my home. Wish I could get this color in a two piece set instead of with the black that I do not wear. P,ease, never stop this color!
Rated 5 out of 5 by LSD62 Linda
LOve ,Love love these eyeliners !!!!!! I put them on in the morning and they look exactly that same at nite when I remove them. I have found nothing that compares to these and their staying power. some people were complaining that they put them on and they rubbed right off. Well as with a lot of liners, you have to wait about 30 seconds or so for them to set., as with a lot of other liners you have about 30 seconds to work with them ,if you want to smudge them or whatever, then they are good to go. Ive given these as gifts also, and they all agree, they are awesome !!!
Rated 4 out of 5 by luv2shop139 Nice Eyeliner BUT....
I really like Mally eyeliner and it does stay on for me. However the thing I DO NOT LIKE is that you have to sharpen it every time you use it or it will rip and stratch your eye! I like to carry it with me at time but dont want to always have to deal with the sharpener. Mally , really I would have thought you would have this self sharpened! Please change this Mally PLEASE!!!
Rated 1 out of 5 by pacificsun NOT BULLETPROOF
I was so excited to get my bullet proof eyeliners so I tried one on immediately. They glide on really nicely but definitely NOT bulletproof. Did a line on my hand and it was easy to rubb off.
Rated 3 out of 5 by flourchylde Not Bullet-Proof
I like these eye liners but they are NOT in any way bullet-proof. I can draw a line on my hand and wipe it right off. I think Mally is playing a little slight-of-hand with us on that one. HOWEVER, they do apply nicely, even if I do have to re-apply in the afternoon. I am really getting tired of the over-the-top statements (yet untrue) statements from the hosts and suppliers when describing products. Hence, I don't shop nearly as much from QVC as I used to.
Rated 5 out of 5 by terp331 Best eyeliner!
I am not big into makeup so I rarely deviate from drugstore brands. I happened to be flipping channels and Mally was on and people were raving about these eyeliners. Now that I've tried them, I can jump on the bandwagon. These pencils glide on super smooth and stay in place even though I have super oily eyelids. The colors are distinct yet I love both the midnight and the sailor! Also it came off easily with a makeup remover! I would definitely recommend.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Review4u BEWARE
I received my products and was so excited to try Mally's eyeliner. They received such great reviews so I thought I would try them. The first morning I tried them they went on smooth and the color was pretty Butttt half way through the afternoon my eyes started to itch terrible so I had to remove the product from my eyes.My eyes continued to itch the remaining evening and night. The next morning I had a rash on my eyelids. I was so disappointed. I never ever broke out in a rash from eye liners before. SO BUYER BEWARE!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sarge1 Caribbean Blue duos
Please offer the duos in one color. I use the Caribbean blue but not the black.
Rated 1 out of 5 by emily51 not as claimed
I like the colors and the way this liner goes on, but it is in no way bullet proof. It doesn't smear on my eyes, it just seems to disappear. I thought it was because I have oily lids, but from the reviews, I guess it is a common problem. I would not buy a Mally product again.
Rated 1 out of 5 by KMan Bullet Proof My Butt
I bought this item because of the "bullet proof" claims. When it arrived, I drew a line on my hand like Mally does. I rubbed it, and it almost immediately disappeared from my hand. In spite of this, I thought I'd try it on my eyes to give it a fair shot. It goes on smoothly, as claimed, because it is so greasy. To keep a sharp point on the pencil, I'd need to sharpen it daily and would use up a pencil in about a week. I work in a climate controlled office and by 10 am, it was already running. I've had better performance out of a drug store brand, costing 1/2 the price. This product does not perform as claimed, and will be going back. Very disappointing.
Rated 5 out of 5 by CarCar BEST EYE LINER EVER!!!!!!!!
I absolutely love this eyeliner in black would love to see a duo, please consider .