Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 37
Rated 5 out of 5 by dbreen43 Best Eyeliner Ever
I normally don't like eyeliners you have to sharpen. These were purchased as a gift for me 3 years ago. My final one is down to a one inch stub and I can't believe your not offering the color choices as before. It goes on so smooth, doesn't scratch or pull and stays on all day. Can't imagine anyone would try these and not love them. Bring back more colors...
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sude Best Ever!!!
This is the best eyeliner ever! Love them in every color. Much better than the regular thin eyeliners.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Terry987 Best Eyeliner I Ever Had
This is the best eyeliner I have ever had. It stays on all day and into evening it looks like they are promoting the skinny ones and they do not work as well as these The skinny eyeliners do not stay on very well. I hope they bring the thicker ones back in every color .
Rated 5 out of 5 by whiterose And the Eyes Have It!
I have always loved Tarte products. I thought that I would give this eyeliner a try for that very reason. My eyelids are extremely oily and even with an eyelid primer, I've had trouble with other product lines. The Smoulder Eyes Eyeliner has surprised me. The application is flawless and the staying power is tremendous. Now if it works on these lids of mine, it will certainly work on yours. Very pleased and will now be reordering in other colors.
Rated 5 out of 5 by big red Love This Item
Being an older lady and not wearing makeup a lot, Ilove this eyeliner. It rolls on so smooth and the point is not a small point that will easily get in the eyes as you put it on. The colors are beautiful. Some of them are sold out, so please bring them all back soon.
Rated 5 out of 5 by D-Mac Best Eyeliner
I love this eyeliner. Stays on all day til you take it off. I have the FIG, CHARCOAL & RAIN FOREST which are no longer available. I wish they would bring them back. Those colors go with everything. Please consider bringing them back.
Rated 4 out of 5 by ldh1028 Best pencil ever
For me, these pencils are the best made by any cosmetics company on the planet. Both the Smoldereyes and Skinnyeyes pencils are color-saturated, long-lasting, and give you enough play time to build the perfectly smudged smoky eye. The reason I'm only giving 4 stars is because QVC charges shipping on makeup which means these pencils cost $3 more than at retail. C for convenience but V isn't Value in the case of cosmetics, especially since you can't see colors until you get items home.
Rated 1 out of 5 by drakey Don't waste your money!!
I love Tart, so I purchased two of these. The colors were very nice, however they need to be sharpened quite often. This is where the problem is. They are impossible to sharpen. I try to sharpen and they just fall apart in the sharpener. Forget even trying to get a point on this eyeliner. I was so disappointed that I just threw them in the trash!!