Rated 3.6 out of 5 by 48
Rated 3 out of 5 by QVCGia Same Problem
This product is fantastic. However there was only about 3 uses in the pen. Just as the others stated. So disappointing for the price. Loved it the 3 times I used it!
Rated 3 out of 5 by JP333 Meh
The self sharpening feature is nice and it does go on very easily/smoothly. I'd prefer to buy just one color. But as far as wearing like iron, not so much. It seems to melt away as quickly as the cheap eyeliner from the drugstore.
Rated 1 out of 5 by pattee Same problem
I love Tarte makeup and I love the eyeliners- if they would last a little longer would be great! I bought the trio. Plum tip broke off and there's no way to get any more product to the top. Tarte needs to correct some problems with their product before I make another purchase. A waste of money!
Rated 4 out of 5 by ShoeLvr89 Love this eyeliner but....
I wish the colors would be sold separately. I use the bronze (LOVE it!) the most and would happily purchase a single or duo pack of one color. Product stays on well most of the day. By the afternoon I do a very minor touch up of smudging around the eye. Please work on selling the colors individually. Thanks!!
Rated 3 out of 5 by CLEVELAND TRY ME - SAMPLE PRODUCTS
The colors are great, easy application and stays on long. Down fall is this is more of a "Try Me" eyeliner set or free gift with purchase . Can not sharpen, I got five applications from this product.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Wings Liked Colors
Liked the product but not much of it. I thought there would be more uses.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Niknik Great eyeliner!
I absolutely LOVE this eyeliner, especially since it has the built-in sharpener. It's very long lasting. I've got one request -- please sell this in singles. Since I use the black color the most, I'd love to buy just another black one.
Rated 3 out of 5 by aegean Mixed Review
I have a different review for each color.
Black - 1 star- Has waxy texture, is difficult to apply and does not stay in place.
Bronze - 3 stars- Better texture and applies easily. Like the base color but not crazy about the "sparkle". Stays for most of the day.
Plum - 4 stars- Good texture, applies easily and lasts all day. Great color.
As for the other reviewers who claim there is not much product - I think they are failing to turn the cap after replacing it on the liner. You have to give it an extra turn to the right, you feel it tighten which is when it advances and sharpens the product.
Would definitely purchase the plum again and a smoky grey color and dark brown if they make them. Would not purchase the black or bronze again