Rated 3.5 out of 5 by 42
Rated 5 out of 5 by guiltypleasures Perfect liner when used correctly!
I love this eyeliner, but noticed many negative reviews. It seems that people are not using the pencil correctly. There is plenty of product but you need to pump it once, when you hear a click the tip has advanced. Maybe a close up on air demonstration and explanation would help.
I have found Tarte to be the best eyeliner I've ever used! It glides on easily, is creamy, has intense color and lasts all day without smearing.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Gemhunt Waste of money Buy Laura Geller eyeliner instead:(
I bought both Laura Geller I-Care waterproof eyeliners and Tarte at the same time. Tarte really disappointed me. Seriously, I liked this product but you only get what is on the tip, A tiny amount? So there wasn't any left inside the tube? I checked the other two in the pack and none of them had any extra product in the tube. I couldn't retract or advance the product? How strange? ;(
Rated 5 out of 5 by Dthompson Pump The Tip!!!
I loved this eyeliner but like a lot of others (as I see from reading reviews) I thought there was very little liner in the tube! I used it for like 2 weeks and it was gone! I was very disappointed because this is great stuff! Never smudges even in the humid South. I was thinking of reordering and read a few reviews. Thank you to whoever stated to pump the tip!! I don't need new eyeliner!! I have plenty left!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by dq111 Stays Put!
This is a wonderful eyeliner that stays on all day, the colors are beautiful and rich, I use all of them. I had a hard time initially with getting how to advance the product from the tube but figured it out by watching the video of the presentation. So if you are deciding whether to get it, please don't be deceived by misconceptions that this is not a full size product, you just need to pump the tip and more eyeliner comes out!
Rated 3 out of 5 by amcargile Does not stay "self-sharpening"
I received these in June and have used them almost daily. The colors are beautiful and they stay put all day. However, the reason I ordered these was for the "self-sharpening" feature. The sharpener is in the lid and the part of the pencil where the actual product comes out pushes down as the lid screws on causing the product to push up and sharpen as you screw on the lid. This sounds perfect. However, after a few weeks the product started building up inside the lid causing the sharpener not to work. Now, I have three blunt tip eyeliners that I don't close the lid on anymore because the gunk build-up in the cap has started caking on the tip of the product causing a big mess.
I gave these three stars because the actual product is exactly what I expected from Tarte; Beautiful, long wearing colors. However, I won't be repurchasing these. I'll stick to the ones that I can sharpen myself.
Rated 1 out of 5 by GMo Hard consistency
This eyeliner is awful. It is the driest, hardest texture I have ever experienced. I missed the return window so I used it until one of them ran out. It did not last very long at all. Not much product in the tube. So, it seemed like a great deal but it was not. Don't waste your money.
Rated 1 out of 5 by jaded defective
I wanted to love but the pencils don't work. They don't roll up all three of them. Sending back to exchange and hope I have better luck with the exchange ones.
We should not have to pay shipping if their products are faulty. Not fair.
Rated 5 out of 5 by NikkiGia123 Great Liner
Loved the Navy, Grey and brown liner. Through this horrible hot humid summer it stayed without smearing until I removed it with my eye makeup remover. Also liked the Maneater mascara. Please bring them back as TSV!!!!! Both products were amazing. Thank you Tarte!!!!