Rated 3.6 out of 5 by 36
Rated 1 out of 5 by jaded defective
I wanted to love but the pencils don't work. They don't roll up all three of them. Sending back to exchange and hope I have better luck with the exchange ones.
We should not have to pay shipping if their products are faulty. Not fair.
Rated 5 out of 5 by NikkiGia123 Great Liner
Loved the Navy, Grey and brown liner. Through this horrible hot humid summer it stayed without smearing until I removed it with my eye makeup remover. Also liked the Maneater mascara. Please bring them back as TSV!!!!! Both products were amazing. Thank you Tarte!!!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by LisDag They PUMP!!
Yup gosh darn it! They PUMP!
I was so frustrated with these and was going to send them right back! I could not figure out how to get the liner out! twisting, shaking, you name it!
Then I read a review... !! ( thank you to whoever wrote it ) These darn things PUMP! Did you ever hear of such a thing?? Lol
Take off the cap, grip the tube near the liner and pull down! Viola! Also mine glide on beautifully. But have had eyeliner in the past from Tarte that was "dry"... Still love Tarte though! Try the clay foundation, love it!
Rated 1 out of 5 by sportsgal misleading eyeliner
i usually love tarte products so when this came out i was so excited. When i opened it and used the liner i thought this is perfect. Now for the kicker. After using the liner after a few weeks there was no more. I just couldnt believe that Tarte would do this. Very misleading. Please DO NOT waste your money on this product.
Rated 4 out of 5 by n225 Great Colors!
I read several of the previous reviews and I am not sure how they can tell there is only a small amount of product. I will assume they have previous purchased this item. I love tarte and they pencils are quite nice. I will keep them and hopefully there is more product than stated in the reviews.
Rated 2 out of 5 by 1southernlady Tiny!
These eyeliners are sample size. However the length of the pencil deceives the buyer to think that it contains a full sized liner. The eyeliner is great, but I do not like deception. Of course I could have searched to compare normal product liner weights to this liner But I trusted I would receive what I saw. I did not.
Rated 5 out of 5 by moo moo tart sharpened colored pencils
It does what it claims to do, just pump the pencil where the lid was (like a pencil) and it will work out.
Rated 1 out of 5 by STARGAZERWAY Bad buy
There's no additional liner in these pencils! You only get a small amount of liner!!! Bad investment for the price!! DO NOT BUY!! save your money!!!!!!!!