Rated 3.6 out of 5 by 48
Rated 4 out of 5 by Amy in Antioch Charmed
I have many different colors of Tarte's lipsurgence, but Charmed (light pink) is my favorite. I agree with another reviewer who said the cap comes off in her purse. Mine does too, but I try to keep it in a makeup bag. I have one in my desk drawer at work, and I love it. I don't notice much of a taste as other reviewers have mentioned. I like that this doesn't feel heavy or cakey on my lips, although I do reapply three or four times daily.
Rated 1 out of 5 by CindiK Tastes Just Awful!!
I ordered this in Grateful. It arrived today and I was anxious to try it. Oh My Gosh.... It tastes absolutely nasty. It smelt like Kerosine, I do not know what is wrong with this but I will not buy again. I have bought many Tarte Products and love them but not this! I saw someone else write a review about the rancid smell and taste of their peach Lip Stain also. Did something go wrong in production??
Rated 4 out of 5 by D17 Beautiful Color
I love the color of this lip stain, it is a little shinier than I expected, I thought it would be a little more matte, but nonetheless the color is peachy perfection.
Rated 2 out of 5 by itneedsmoreglitter Not a stain but pretty moisturizing colors
Got several shades of these and love them though after a while a lot of the pink shades basically look the same. My main problem is that they are not a stain in any way, shape, or form. They wear off quickly and are basically a balm.
Rated 5 out of 5 by WillEscapeCAsoon Really nice.
If your looking for a semi but not quite nude, Grateful is really good. Sort of a deeper peach with a bit of a goldish cast to the shade. Not a stain however, more moisturizing than that. More a lip creme. Lucky is a pretty pale pink nice for a light pink but use sparingly or it will look too 60's light. Hope is a shade darker than my natural lips which are sort of a medium mauve and its nice if you want a bit more color. Hope and Lucky are true stains. Don't be expecting a lot of moisture, but they do the trick and last a long time and don't dry you out. Depending on your coloring these three should be doable on pretty much anyone without washing you out. I highly recommend these three shades. Do yourself a favor and order during cooler months. I lost one last year to heat in transit. Still very much worth it however.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Carole W Rancid
This had the smell and taste of being old and rancid. Peach color was nice but I threw in the trash. Normally I am very pleased with Tarte. Maybe this isn't a popular color and has been in the warehouse too long. I personally liked the color. I won't let this prevent me from ordering Tarte items in the future but won't order the lip stain again. I've ordered previously in the pink colors and found it had a peppermint taste which I liked. Maybe this was just a bad batch.
Rated 2 out of 5 by USAir Ret Nice Texture
But leaves the lips fast! Pretty color! Lid keeps coming off in my purse! Not worth the cost! I would purchase Laura Geller first and hers does everything that she promises! Sorry Tarte just not a good product for me!
Rated 5 out of 5 by KMS19 Everything you want from a Lip Product
It has amazing color, staying power, and really good moisturizer for your lips, even if first thing on your lips in morning! Much more moisturizing than the previous lipsurgence stain I had, but the first one's staying power was better too. I think because it was less moisturizing, but I'd take moisturizing over color any day. You can always reapply!