Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 2290
Rated 1 out of 5 by Cyndieeee Terrible
I was desperate and thought I would try this brand one more time. Terrible mistake. I should have learned from the last time. But I thought I would try again hoping this brand had improved, NOPE! Still the worst! Still gloppy!
Rated 1 out of 5 by tngypsy Tarte much better
I've been using this for 3 months now, and I see nothing great about it. Sure if you apply about 4 layers, you get big spider leg looking lashes. The brush is really plain and the mascara flakes. I have used Tarte mascara for several years and thought I'd give Mally a try, but will never stray again. So overpriced!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Betty Spagetti LOVE IT!
I am 55 years old (a young 55) I have tried every mascara from Department Store brands to High End Boutiques. I was watching QVC one evening and I saw the demonstration that Mally did on her mascara.I ordered the 6 pack for a one time only price. Well, I was thrilled with this product. I have been using it for 2 years now. I even gave each of my 2 daughters a tube and they are also hooked! I recently placed another order and will continue to use this product forever. Really love it, thanks Mally
Rated 1 out of 5 by Thrifty Disappointed
I bought this mascara as part of a six pack special. I looked like a racoon at the end of the day. Malli says her products are "bullet proof", but the mascara is not smudge proof. I used Cover Girl mascara on one eye, and Malli's on the other. The CG provided just as much volume, but did not leave black under my eye in a matter of a few hours. Returned today, and will never purchase again.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Samtheshopper Great used with curler
For some reason, when I saw Mally on QVC demonstrating this product on the models, it worked so well without having to curl lashes. So of course I had to give it a try. I have medium length lashes, and my lash problem type is that they stick straight out. Even when I curl them prior to applying mascara, sometimes they will just fall flat again immediately after. So, when I first used this product without the curler, my lashes were still straight, but after using my curler (drug store brand), and then applied the mascara in between curls, it lasted all day.
Rated 1 out of 5 by janettentucson Awful!!
I love most of Josie's products but this one, not so much.Could not get past the smell,reminded me of rotting vegetables, sorry Josie,sending back!
Rated 1 out of 5 by kalgal Not Good
Looked great on air but in person not so much. It was very clumpy and messy to apply. Perhaps the brush a bit too big. Had my sister try it as well but thumbs down. Had to return it.
Rated 5 out of 5 by DoubleRR W*O*W!!!
I LOVE this mascara. I have to admit I was skeptical because I thought the models had thick, luscious lashes before even applying but I've been a Mally fan for years and have many of her other products so I finally broke down and tried this. WOW! I am in love. It really does what it says it is going to do and makes my lashes long, thick, plush, dark, bold and BEAUTIFUL. I have blue eyes with light lashes but not with this mascara - now I don't even have to wear liner. I just put on this mascara and my eyes pop. Totally impressed. Thank you Mally!
Rated 5 out of 5 by wykons Best ever
Love this mascara, but learned to only order the 2 pack not the 6 pack special even tho you save a little money. By the time I used all the 6 tubes, 1 was totally dry and one had leaked. SO, I only use this mascara but make sure to order 2 at a time. Have tried so many other brands and nothing compares to the length, volume and easy removal of Mally's.
Rated 5 out of 5 by texasgranny Best Mascara For Me
I have thin short eyelashes. This mascara makes my lashes look longer and thicker that my fellow coworkers have noticed. I have not found anything else that works for me. I use the non waterproof one. It's very easy to remove in the shower and am careful not to go to a sad movie or go swimming with it on.
Rated 5 out of 5 by CristelRV In Love
I have fallen in love with this mascara! After using this I can never go back to my drug store mascara. Even higher end mascaras flake and tighten my skin. With one sweep of this, my lashes look thicker and longer! The best part is how soft my lashes feel! I don't feel like I have pins and needles for lashes after using this product! Recommend recommend!
Rated 2 out of 5 by Marmaduke66 Something has changed.
I have used this mascara for years and loved it. Gave it for Christmas presents and told my family and friends how great it was. Was. That's the key word. The last two tubes have been very gloppy and overloaded on the brush and the tip. It's like the rubber at the top of the tube isn't working properly and not removing the excess off the brush. I'm not sure why, but it isn't the same; so I'm looking for another mascara.