Rated 3.8 out of 5 by 2395
Rated 1 out of 5 by AbigailH Very Disappointed
After seeing the product on QVC I wanted to try this mascara. Don't do it! Whatever mascara they used on TV is not what I received in my order. It is goopy and clumpy. So much mascara comes out on the brush and then my lashes are a disaster. I try to comb them out but it doesn't help much. I would rather buy the $6 drugstore brand I used before. I will NEVER buy this again. Unfortunately I bough the duo so I have two tubes to get through.
Rated 2 out of 5 by sunnysouth I agree...something has changed!
I have used this mascara for years. Being "eyelash challenged" I would sometimes try something new/different, but would always go back to Mally. After trying a couple of other products, I went back to my stock of Mally from my previous auto delivery and wondered why I ever bothered with anything else. THEN, I ordered a duo so I would not run out (even after reading recent bad reviews). I am very disappointed with this last order. It is most definitely not the same. I don't know if the formulation changed or the brush or both. I do know that I have to really tug to get the brush out of the container...makes me wonder about that. This is really sad. There were so many lovers of this product (it won awards...was customer top rated). If it was changed, why??? If it was changed...can you change it back? It wasn't broken! Now it seems thick and goopy. Now I'm going to have to search for a new mascara. :-(
Rated 5 out of 5 by Rita Liz Best mascara ever
This is the only mascara for me. Really volumizes lashes, doesn't flake off. I ran out of Mally mascara and bought drugstore mascara - last time for that. This is worth every penny!!!
Rated 1 out of 5 by lucy12 Worst Mascara EVER!!!
I had heard about this for a long time,so I decided to try it! It is clumpy.No length no separation! I was going to send it back but went in the hospital and missed the time limit! An 8$ drug store brand works so much better!
Rated 1 out of 5 by cjthomas3906 What happened!?
I have used this mascara for years and loved it! However, the past three tubes have been awful. The mascara does not lengthen and it is clumpy. What a disappointment!
Rated 1 out of 5 by Jabberjaw Not The Same
This was my favorite mascara for years. As others have mentioned, something changed. The last few auto-shipments were either dried out or gummy. I delayed my shipments after reading the reviews. I finally ordered the anniversary 6 tube package and since it was taking so long to receive, I thought that Mally had heard the complaints and corrected the issue. NOT. The first tube I opened was gummy. My lashes stuck together and I had to use a lash comb to separate the clumps. Not good. Not sure if I will return because of the postage, but I will not be re-ordering.
Rated 1 out of 5 by n2chaos Yikes!!!
I've used this mascara for more than 5 yrs and recommended it to all my friends.
Whatever they did to the formula...this is NOT the mascara that I'm accustomed to. I read other reviews commenting on the formula and thought they were bogus until I got my new order. This formula makes my lashes look thin and wet, not thick and lush. Maybelline here I come!
Rated 1 out of 5 by ulddaisy Awful!
This was the best mascara ever, but you cheaped out and changed the formula. Now it's garbage. You have lost another loyal customer. I will never buy anything from Mally again.
Rated 1 out of 5 by christieg Too Bad...
What has happened to this amazing mascara???!!!
I have used Mally's Volumizing Mascara for YEARS. It has been my favorite for so long and I'm sad to have to move to a new product.
What used to be perfect, is now a clumpy, sticky mess. Yes you can work with it and try to make it look decent... but it is nothing like it used to be. Too much comes out on the wand and it's impossible to keep it from happening no matter how you try to clean it off. I hoped it was just a bad tube, but unfortunately not. I honestly got to the point where I literally dreaded applying my mascara... afraid it wouldn't turn out right and I'd have to wear a mess all day.
My eyes looked caked and dry. And who knows why (must be part of the formula change), but it became much more difficult to remove. After cleansing it would be under my eyes still in a waxy sort of consistency.
I hope this echo of the other reviews is helpful to someone else.... It's not your imagination, something has gone badly wrong with this product!
Rated 1 out of 5 by ziggystardust What's Happened???
Mally's mascaras have completely changed. What happened to the Instant Impact mascara, I ordered it all the time on QVC..now you can't find it anywhere not even on her website....it looks like it has been discontinued. Boo! I have used the Volumizing and the Ginormous mascaras...they are epic failures...clumpy, flaky and they dry out fast! I agree with many QVC Mally fans..something had changed with the formula, it is not the same! Please bring the old formula and PLEASE bring back the Instant Impact...it was the bomb!
Rated 2 out of 5 by wickedscents What's going on?!
Unfortunately, I have to agree with these recent reviews...something has changed! I've been using this mascara for years and loved it. It's on auto-ship and the last few shipments have been inferior...probably a year of defects thinking back on it. I thought it was just me, but I can see from the reviews that I'm not alone. Seems like a manufacturing problem or something...sometimes it's the tube or brush with a defect, and sometimes it's the mascara itself. It's only good for a couple of weeks before it starts clumping on the brush and then your lashes. SO disappointed...I don't even know where to turn for a new brand since this was my all-time favorite!
Rated 5 out of 5 by elliedesign Mally's the BEST!
Mally's Volumizing Mascara is the only mascara I use. I have skimpy eyelashes. When I apply it, my lashes are thick and long, with no clumping. Two coats and I have the lashes I wish I was born with. Also, I have never lost an eyelash since using this product. With other products my lashes would fall out and the mascara would flake and fall on my face. Not with Mally! I will always be a Mallenista! Why change when you have found perfection? And you can not be at QVC's price. I have paid over $20 retail for one tube. QVC gives me two. It is not ROCKET SCIENCE. It is a great beauty product! Love you Mally!