Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 2315
Rated 2 out of 5 by katie11 Very disappointed
I always buy the set of six mascaras, for some reason the last batch is not the same as I have been using for years. The mascara is very thick, clumps up on my lashes, and it's just not the same. I will not buy anymore until you go back to the old formula that was the best, why would you change?
Rated 1 out of 5 by little1 This Mascara Is Not The Same!
Mally, loved your mascara. Not this time ordered you set of two. Something has changed...the mascara does not have the body that your previous product had. Seems like the brush itself is not the same! I loved your mascara,not this one. I won't be ordering any more! Bring back your mascara you are known for!
Rated 2 out of 5 by susicuse Disappointed
Expected more from this mascara. Got better results from drugstore brand. Going back to Tarte! Don't know why I changed. Tarte is still the best.
Rated 5 out of 5 by IGon We Love It
I absolutely love how long my eyelashes are every time I wear the mascara, my daughter also loves it, everyone always asks what kind of mascara we wear. Highly recommend it. We have used it for a couple of years and we will use it for many more years to come.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Cody and Lisa Doesn't do what it says it does
I love Loreal's Carbon Black Volumizing mascara, I've tried every mascara ever created from regular drug store prices to $80, vibrating mascaras and they are all disappointing. This mascara was advertised with so much enthusiasm by the lady that makes them and the announcer simply by running it over your lashes twice and suddenly their as long as the vines growing on the side of my house?! So I bought it and was really excited.....NOT! It took just as long to get my lashes as full as it would with any other drug store mascara, and the length wasn't any different. I'll stick with my Loreal Carbon Black, it has remained a true volumizer for me for the last 7-8 years, so I guess I'll stick with what works for me, b/c this one did not.
Rated 1 out of 5 by LinnyCA NOT GOOD
I received my duo in the mail the other day & tried it before going to work, this mascara is horrible. Mascara is the one makeup item I can not live without, so when I seen this on the live broadcast & all the great things that were being said about it I had to have it. Huge disappointment, it is very clumpy, did not give me any length or volume, I had to go back over it with my smashbox mascara to try & declump it a little bit. I will be returning the duo for sure. I also purchased the highlighter from ulta not too long back & was very disappointed with that as well, it worked for the first 10 applications or so but now will not even pick up with my brush to apply. So overall I am not a big fan of the Mally products due the 2 not so great products that I have purchased. Very disappointed bc I so much wanted to love this mascara & wanted it to make my lashes look like the models on the show, but sadly it did not...
Rated 5 out of 5 by vanillacake22 AMAZING!!!!!
I am so happy I gave this a try. My lashes are long, dark and thick with this mascara.
Absolutely could not be happier.
I will never use anything else.
Rated 5 out of 5 by heygiff Not sure at first
When I was apply this mascara I was not totally impressed. After I came home and was ready to take my makeup off it look like my lashes had grown. I am thinking too hot to not keep buying. A winner.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Beauty geek Not the same
I was so glad to read some recent reviews of this mascara. I have the auto delivery and I too have noticed the last couple of times the product is different. Mine even seems to be old or dried out, but DEFINITELY not the same as before. I thought I had just gotten an "old" batch, but after reading some of the reviews, that doesn't seem to be the case. I'm ready to cancel my auto delivery if they don't go back to the old formula. This always happens to me - I find something I really like in a makeup product and they either stop making it or change it. Very frustrating!
Rated 2 out of 5 by nanabev Too Thick
I totally agree about this mascara-it's not from the same manufacturer. Had to send 2 back because the entire inside came out at once- way too thick & doesn't go on smoothly. Sorry, have to find another brand
Rated 5 out of 5 by bamabelle10 Love this!!!
I have virtually "no eyelashes" to speak of but this makes me look like I do! I can apply 2 good coats and my eyelashes look and feel great. I wish I'd found this years ago. And it doesn't flake like a lot of others I've tried in the past. Try it, you'll love it!
Rated 1 out of 5 by CatherineTheGreat Bleeds at the drop of a single tear ......
Great mascara BUT if you ever tear up or laugh so hard you eyes well up then this is not the mascara for you unless you don't mind having it all over your face ! Also after a few hours it will flake off and get into your eyes and when you try a remove the flake(s) your eye waters and then the rest of the mascara runs all over your face. Would love to use this mascara if it were WATERPROOF !!!!