Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 2354
Rated 3 out of 5 by sbj1104 Expensive mistake
This is no better than Maybelline Rocket Volum' Express Mascara in my opinion. I get lots of compliments on my lashes, which are long and plush using it, with no clumps. I use makeup primer first to ensure a smooth, oil-free canvas to start, then do the backside of my lashes and then the underside #front that most people do#, rocking the brush side to side simultaneously to get volume. I don't do the bottom lashes. My tips are left with no clumps, each lash separated nicely. I go over it a few times until I get good volume, but stop before anything gets tarantula looking. In style or not, I HATE that look.
I tried the same technique with Mally. It seems very wet in comparison and tends clump much easier than the aforementioned mascara, despite the primer. I had to finish by separating the lashes with a comb. I was not able to get my lashes to elongate up to my eyebrow, and I didn't notice any 'patent' shine. I'll use up the tube I've opened, try to find someone else to give the unopened tube away to #hard, because everyone I know goes plain faced or just wears lipstick# and go back to Maybelline Rocket. Wanted to like but...
Rated 1 out of 5 by punkinny What Has Happended To This Mascara
I have used this mascara for a long time which I have remained on auto delivery. Mally, what has happened to your mascara? I just received two brand new tubes -this is only the third day and it is the biggest mess -the tube comes out totally covered with so much mascara that I have to try to work most of it back in the tube-I am talking EVERY time it reloads it comes out a mess. I will remove it from AD and I am contemplating if I want to return it due to shipping cost. Mally and QVC - Mally you need to go back to the drawing board on this one and QVC you should waive the return shipping charge for such a poor product.
Rated 1 out of 5 by petite shopper Once a favorite...but no more!
I have been using this mascara for years and years, but the formula in my recent auto delivery is totally different. The brush came out overloaded with mascara and went on too thick and clumped. When I combed it with my mascara brush, it flaked all over my cheeks and not much was left on my lashes. The second coat was even worse. I noticed that almost every review since the last auto delivery is a one-star Poor. I'm returning mine and canceling the AD that I have had for probably ten years.
Rated 1 out of 5 by spice c Mascara gone bad
This is my second review and hope potential buyers heed warnings. I have used this mascara since QVC started selling...loved it. But....it appears something has changed as for prox. one year now, it is gooey and clumpy and you can not apply it. I agree with other reviews as for the poor quality. The cartridge also comes right out of the tube making it useless. Hope this helps.
Rated 1 out of 5 by ninnie Dry
I have been using this product for several years and have loved it,however the last time I ordered it was not the same!! It seems to be too thick and dry.Has the product changed????
Rated 3 out of 5 by tlw816 What's Happened?
This has always been my favorite mascara, I always have a six month supply for me and have bought it for my friends and my daughters! Something has changed though, cause its always very clumpy and leaves eyelash marks under my brows. It's never left marks before no matter how long I've kept it on! Please go back to what you were using in this before cause I've seen lots of others have said the same things!
Rated 5 out of 5 by phillypatty The Eyes have it.
Mally girl, thank you for all your hard work. It is so appreciated. Girls from 17 to 67 and more love this product. Does what you say. Love you, Patty xo
Rated 1 out of 5 by 151 holdings Worst mascara
This mascara is not a good product. It does not volumize or lengthen the lashes at all, but it is clumpy. It gushes out and is totally messy. I feel it is not represented accurately on television.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Patti24 Disappointed
Very disappointed!!!! Maybelline works better and is much cheaper. I bought the pack of 6 and all are dried out and comes out in big clumps.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Heidired Clumps
I was impressed by the presentation, but this did not work for me. Clumps at times and seems very thick..
Rated 2 out of 5 by RachelrooZ Raccoon eyes
If you are using an oil-based make-up, you'll get quite bad raccoon eyes underneath.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Steph C Used To Love This
The last several times I've ordered this mascara, only one of the tubes was usable. The second tube has been a clumpy mess. Won't be re-ordering.