It Cosmetics TIGHTLINE Full Lash Line Black Mascara Primer Duo
This product did not do as promised. I saw no difference in the length or thickness of my lashes at all. It just coated them, that was it. I will use one for my lower lashes, but tossed out the others. I expected a better product.
Not for me...
I have high expectations for IT cosmetics unfortunately, I was not impressed with Tightline. Maybe with practice, the modeled result can be achieve but, I am a no fuss - just deliver kind of gal... I will stay with Lancome Definicil (one coat, extending, smudge proof & it washes off 'effortlessly' with Philosophy) for the same price.
Not so great!
I was excited to try this mascara. Definitely different approach for application with the tiny wand brush. I LOVED it for my lower lashes; that being said not so great on the top lashes. My eyelashes didn't look longer, went straight and it was a horrible task to try to remove. It did add a little look of liner though. I actually ordered the trio and couldn't justify keeping three tubes for just my lower lashes. May purchase just one tube for that purpose.
Pretty good concept
Love the tiny brush, as I hate the long brushes poking me in the eye! But I don’t get a lot of length from this, which is what I really wanted, not much product coming out on the brush. In spite of that, I like “It” and “Tarte” cosmetics, especially because they are cruelty-free, and that means a lot to me.
Plus and Minus
Plus; The brush is the best. Works best for giving the look of eyeliner. Goes on smooth and makes lashes long and lush.
Minus; It flakes, flakes and it flakes. Difficult to remove from lashes.
Please improve the formula. The brush is perfect.
I love this product! It isn't mascara to be worn alone, but it separates your lashes and gives them a beginning of color. I especially love the application wand! I put it on first, then add my mascara on top. I used up my old mascara and the ordered the IT mascara on top. I can't say enough good things about it.
Not a good concept
I have been on a quest for a decent mascara, I ain't found it yet. Thought I might with this, but with the brush so small it's even hard to get any mascara on your lashes. Going back
I couldn't believe how easily this mascara made my lashes dark AND separate with NO (that's NO!# clumping.... I got three mascaras in the excellent buy, so I gave my daughter one. She left the vanity and came out with her mouth open and her eyes big and blinking #extravagantly overdone). She said, "I will never use another mascara. I didn't have even one clump to deal with." On the down side she hadn't heard of IT cosmetics before, but I told her no bother, I have a secret source. I haven't worked with it to get the line, because I like to use liner, but for the excellent color and separation I get with this mascara, it's the one I will use from now on. Way to go, IT!!!
I was disappointed to see that there is hardly any mascara in each tube... this was a total waste of money.
Not for me !
I was very disappointed in this. No matter how many times I reviewed the instructions and applied, it never worked well. It never covered my lashes evenly or well, ended up cakey, flakey and hard; also poked myself in the eyes several times. The only use I found for this was to extend my lashes after applying my regular Lancome mascara. Then, I was stuck with cleaning it off... very messy. I threw them both out.
Was very disappointed in this product. Bristles on brush much too small to apply to lashes.
on the fence
I wanted to try this because I liked the idea of liner look with mascara on days that I don't do my full makeup but still some ,mascara and eyeliner but it doesn't work for me in looking like I have eyeliner. I read the instructions on the website too on how to give the look of eyeliner and for me it doesn't work. I don't have sparse lashes, I have pretty long lashes and full so I don't know if that has anything. As a regular mascara its just okay. I'm still going to try to get this to work but I really don't think I would reorder as I do love ITS cc cream, cc concealer and hello light cream! Oh and their powder products cause of my extremely dry skin but this not so good.