Rated 3.6 out of 5 by 40
Rated 5 out of 5 by sarah13 Holy Grail Of Mascara
First off, this mascara truly is water proof. It has lasted without a smear or smudge thru allergy season, many a shark week melt down and even maintained my curled lashes, watery eyes and all.
Now, that being said, good luck trying to remove it without the super secret trick. Olive oil! Rub a bit of olive oil between your thumb and index finger and gently rub your eyelashes, the mascara magically will come off with very little effort. No makeup remover will take this stuff off, and if it budges I would have water proof mascara smeared under my eyes and would be stuck looking like a raccoon.
If you have lashes like mine that are straight and long that hang like snuffaluffagus, curl them and always use water proof mascara. Your curl will hold all day!
Rated 1 out of 5 by lov2shop183 First hour flaked
Disappionted from the moment I opened product. The mascara is dry and cakey. Much to my surprise, it flaked off within the first hour.and smeared under my eyes. Love many of Mally's products but certainly not going to purchase this one again.
Rated 1 out of 5 by monseratt 22 the freakiest experience with mascara ever!!!!!
Yes this is waterproof. My makeup remover would not take it off i had to use my special one. But But But. It smudged all over when i took a short nap. And I wore to yoga and had the biggest raccoon eyes. it totally came off. and i do not go to a hard sweaty class. it is the strangest stuff. Mally you messed up big time with this. I am mad. I have waterproof mascara from Mac and they do not lie. It does not come off... And the craziest thing of all is I love your regular mascara very much. please can't you come up with a really true bullet proof mascara. please...........................
Rated 5 out of 5 by Catlover50 Love this mascara
I've been using Mally's Waterproof Volumizing Mascara for about a week now.
I just love it, It really stays on - bulletproof - as Mally would say! But it comes off easily with makeup remover. I'll be shopping with Mally again, soon!
Rated 3 out of 5 by latoria IT'S OK, NOT THE BEST
When i first received it, i immediately tried it out. I love the way it made my eyes look. It brought out the volume & length which i thought was amazing. My lashes were dark and full just the way i like them. The only problem i have with this product is i don't think its 100% waterproof like its suppose to be. I was a little bit disappointed. I thought that id had finally hit the jackpot with this but i was totally wrong!!!!!!!!!
Rated 1 out of 5 by fredo Terrible mascara
This mascara is awful. It runs under my eyes it clumps up and the brush is terrible. I am surprised because usually Mally is very good.
Rated 1 out of 5 by mkmartin Disappointed
I've watched Mally present her mascara numerous times. I decided to give it a try. For the first time ever, a mascara came off on my eyelids. After two days of this, I sent it back. I don't care how soft the mascara makes my lashes feel, I want it to stay on. I only wear mascara on my eyes.
Rated 1 out of 5 by crickmills Smudgey Eyes
The mascara was good until about 4 or 5 hours after applying, then it looked like you had smeared it all under your eyes. Didn't think that waterproof was supposed to do that. I'll be returning this product.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Kimwill Not Waterproof
Your lashes look really good when you put it on, but it doesn't appear to be waterproof. I agree with what someone else posted. Usually by lunch time or early afternoon, it looked like I had racoon eyes underneath my eyes. It is embarassing...looked like I had been crying. I tried it for several days. I'm returning it...sorry.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Firewater Beautiful Black
This is a wonderful, STAY PUT, mascara. You will need makeup remover to get it off, but that is a bonus. The only drawback is you have to be light handed and do it one layer at a time, or it will clump. Wonderful, wonderful.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Corkie Can not get this off!
This would be great for a day at the beach or pool. However, this stuff is not only water proof but apparently soap & water proof and eye makeup remover proof! I have only used it one time so far, but thought I would NEVER get it off..
Rated 2 out of 5 by Lapisphere Lasts, but does NOT remove easily!
I received this in a 9-piece kit, meant for warmer weather. All products in kit were truly waterproof, including this mascara. Unfortunately, application was rough, as it pulled at my lashes each time I'd pass the wand. And when it came time to remove, I had to really work in an oil-based makeup remover. It was too much work. Not a horrible product, but not worth the hassle.