Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 212
Rated 3 out of 5 by SillyShopper Loved it at first
I got my first tubes of this mascara from QVC as part of a special set. They were the black colored tubes, not the normal white ones. I don't know if that had anything to do with it, but it seems like all the white tubes I've purchase since then have messed up the product and the application. The first couple of times I use the tube it's okay, but then the mascara starts to come out all clumpy and makes a mess on the sides of the tube and on my lashes. I love how the product initially makes my lashes look, but after a couple of uses it's pretty messy. Quite frankly, this product is too expensive to be used a couple of times and then thrown out. Judging by the number of other reviews that are complaining about the same issue, I guess it's not just a fluke. I won't be purchasing this product anymore until I see reviews that say the problem has been fixed.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Okiegirl What's up?
I've been buying Mally's mascara for years but the last two mascara haven't been up to the quality of previous ones. I loved it because I have allergies and it didn't run when my eyes watered. A great plus. But the last two have clumped after only using for two weeks and I can't get it to separate the lashes. Has the formula been changed? If so, I'll probably be going back to my old Maybelline mascara.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Ooci Boo
I have used Mally mascara for years; however, the last two orders have been unacceptable! The wand comes out CLUMPY and I have to wipe it down before I can use it. I'm not sure if Mally has changed formula or what! I used it for years with great results--now...NO!
Rated 2 out of 5 by lindseyinla Bring the old brush back!
I purchased the 6 pack of mascara in July and was so excited to score it since I have missed it in the past. I was disappointed when I received it because it seems as though the brush on the mascara wand had changed. The new brush is awful and changes the application of the product. I am hopeful that the old version of the brush is available with other retailers and perhaps this was just for the 6 pack run of the product.
Loved the other version, Mally, please change it back!
Rated 2 out of 5 by NurseRonda Raccoon eyes
I ordered the six pack of mascara. I gave both of my daughters on. I wore some yesterday to work. When I left the house my eyes looked great, but when I got home I had terrible raccoon eyes. This mascara did not stay put it was on my upper lids and under my eyes. I was horrified I looked like that. I would send them back but since I gave one to each daughter I cannt ask for them back. I will give each daughter two more each. I am not using this mascara again.
Rated 3 out of 5 by ProudGrandma Nice Mascara
I can say that this is a nice mascara, but really no better than the L'Oreal Volumizing Mascara I buy at the drugstore. I will use what I have, but doubt that I'll be paying the extra price to buy more. Good mascara...just not "great" mascara.
Rated 1 out of 5 by chosenone Disappointed Customer
I was so looking forward to receiving this mascara because it was a Mally product.. I have very thin and sparse eyelashes was looking for a nice volume but it was barely noticeable. I was resigned just to use it anyway but then came the clumping. I am going to return it for a refund. Very disappointed in this product.
Rated 5 out of 5 by shorebird27 The BEST at any price!
This is absolutely the BEST mascara I have ever used regardless of price. I was loyal to a department store brand for years but after trying this mascara, I will never go back. I have short, sparse lashes and this formula fills them in and thickens them up. Its thick enough to plump them up but not so thick that it clumps. Love the two pack, love the auto delivery. Wish all products were as outstanding as this - did I tell you how much I love it? ;-)
Rated 5 out of 5 by typical shopper BEST MASCARA
I HAVE TRIED MANY DIFFERENT MASCARAS AND THIS ONE WAS A WINNER FOR ME . GOES ON EASILY AND STAYS ALL DAY .DOESN'T IRRITATE MY EYES. LOVE THIS PRODUCT. THANKS MALLY
Rated 1 out of 5 by longliveqvc horrible mascara
I purchased this in a 6 pack around the holidays since there were so many positive reviews on it. It was horrible!! It does NOT work as they show on TV adding great length and volume to eyelashes and clumps up in the tube making a mess after a few uses. Trash item!! Sorry, I am going back to a brand that QVC use to carry (begins with a P) that I have always loved but the Q stopped carrying it. Please bring that brand back to the Q! Don't waste your money on this one.
Rated 2 out of 5 by CatherineH It smudges and flakes
I was excited to order this mascara after watching the on-air presentation but unfortunately am disappointed with this Mally product. It flakes really badly as the day goes on and smudges easily.
Rated 5 out of 5 by JSW1 BEST MASCARA I'VE EVERY USED!
Wow...I have a very hard time believing ANY of these bad reviews, and can't help thinking these people are paid to write bad reviews by competing cosmetic companies.
I purchased this mascara about a month ago and it is the ONLY mascara I've ever used that kept my lashes UP! My old brand of mascara did nothing to keep my lashes up, even after using an eyelash curler. I would always have to apply another coat of mascara before leaving for work. Even then, my lashes ultimately drooped and the mascara smudged under my eyes.
I've never had a problem with Mally's mascara flaking, clumping, or smudging. It's the best mascara I've ever tried and will continue to purchase it.