Rated 3.3 out of 5 by 15
Rated 2 out of 5 by okiejonesy Disappointed
I was so excited to see these available but so disappointed when I took them out of the package. The large platter is way too narrow and the small platter just too small altogether. I kept them thinking I would find some use for them but tried to serve a ham at Easter and juice ran all over because it was too narrow and because there is not much of a lip too hold drippings. I will also agree with others that the painting on these was not good. Sorry, I love my Temptation but not these so much.
Rated 5 out of 5 by JMelissaMc Beautiful Platters!
I was one of the lucky few to get these platters in Egg Hunt. I have proudly displayed them on my Dining Room table for several weeks now and they have brightened up the table. I have a pink floral arrangement sitting in the middle of the large one. Very versatile and I really like the colors. Highly recommend!
Rated 3 out of 5 by DrKayMS ok but...
These platters are pretty in the red floral lace, but the small one is too small for very much - I'm using it in the bathroom to hold the jewelry I take off and want a place to put it that is the same every time. The larger one is fine for many things, but like other reviewers have said, it is very flat and things spill off of it. It would be nice if it had a one inch lip on it all the way around. I will keep mine because I will use them but I think this needs a little bit of redesign.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Amyluvsjewelry Not quite what I was expecting
I was looking forward to these, but upon inspection I noticed the paint is inconsistent. Parts of the red in the floral design are lighter on one side, and darker on the other. Also, the design itself is not symmetrical or centered. Poor quality items do not receive positive reviews.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Pitbull Needs Some Tweaking
I was excited to finally be able to purchase these platters in OW Red. Since receiving, I have used them almost every day. My biggest disappointment is how extremely flat they are; all the juices from the food on the platter spills off and makes a huge mess everywhere! They would be so much nicer if the rims were sloped upwards so that everything stayed on the platter. The small platter is very small and is very flat as well. The painting on both platters was very nicely done--a pleasant surprise after several recent disappointments. There are variations in the color of the red between the platters and my other pieces, but it won't be noticeable enough to make a difference when there is food on them. I would personally prefer that they were more oval shaped instead of tapered like a football. I would also like to see an even larger platter offered in traditional OW, since I cook for a crowd--9 kids, husband, and hands helping on our family farm.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Anthony B Poor Quality
These were bad as they had bumps of clay on them, which were glazed over. These were returned.
Rated 3 out of 5 by DIL Didn't love these
I am keeping because I threw out the packaging.
I don't like the pointing of the edges
They looked more oval on presentation.
The small one is too small.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Norasnana Wonderful
I purchased this set in Old World Springfetti and it is wonderful. The colors immediately brought spring into my home. No issue with paint as some have said. I love the idea of stacking them for a buffet table.