Temp-tations Old World Cookie Sheet w/ 2 EZ Hold Bakers
Great gift idea!
Got two sets of these for gifts! What a gem! Receivers were pleased and enjoyed them! works for me!
glad I didn't pay full price for them
I have not baked in them yet...only small cold serving or reheat in microwave so far. Nice set, sizes...but like the others, have paint strokes and color settled in the corners. I am assuming this is why the set is on clearance..just to get rid of. I would not keep them if I paid full price for them...but the clearance price is pretty good so I will keep them. I am not sure if I will place the cookie sheet in anything over 350F....planned on using it as a tray mostly.
Rating Review: Minus 0
This is at least my third return of the Temptations pottery. The painting is Awful on them; where is the "Quality Control"? My cookie sheet and bakers have brush marks across them with paint settlement in the corners. This problem is due to "Not Being Fired Long Enough and Hot Enough of a Firing in the Kiln" I do ceramics and have two kilns that I use to fire the greenware. These pieces are not acceptable in this condition. I returned these as well as others. I will not be purchasing anymore Temptations. This problem could easily be fixed if someone was checking the pottery that comes out of the kiln. There is not Quality Control with this pottery. That's another reason for so many of them getting broken. In the beginning the quality was good, but has definitely gone down hill. I find this problem all the time now. I Do Not Recommend these to anyone!!
MINE BROKE TOO
I TOO HAD THE COOKIE SHEETS.. NOT THIS ONE BUT THE 9X13..I USED IT NORMALLY BAKING COOKIES AND IT BROKE IN HALF ALSO... I AM VERY DISAPPOINTED BECAUSE TEMPTATIONS ISN'T SUPPOSED TO DO THAT.. I REALLY LOVED BAKING COOKIES ON THESE .. THEY ARE AWESOME FOR BAKING. I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHAT IS CAUSING THEM TO BREAK IN HALF..I HOPE THEY FIX THE PROBLEM.
Bad Cookie Sheet
I love the concept of this set but the cookie sheet snapped in two after about 3 months of moderate use. It broke as I removed it from my oven set at 350. Customer service was very nice and would have replaced the set, however I would have had to send all the pieces back and pay $9 in postage. I really love the two little bakers and some reviewers said the paint job was not good on their sets. So, rather than risk getting an inferior set of bakers, I decided to just keep them and throw the cookie sheet away. Very disappointed. I have a lot of Temp-tations and this is the first bad experience I have had.
Disappointed… Really badly paintedPosted
"My first Temp-tations order.. (with Q-from the start) I ordered the blue, it came on 3/28/13 and I returned it on 3/29..
Very Disappointed in the paint also.
I have wanted to order in the past but just don’t have room, what with all my
Q… pots-pans & lock & lock. etc. Before this came.
I ordered the Confetti 9x13 baker.. w/lid etc.. Hope the paint is better on it..
Just Perfect For Cookies
I purchased these - I bought two of them - Temp-tations Old World Cookie Sheets w/2 EZ Hold Bakers when my original oval serving platter (also Temp-tations) broke after using it umpteen times, over several years, for cooking chocolate chip cookies. The serving platter that I originally had fit perfectly into my small electric (toaster) oven when it was set diagonally, while the larger oblong Temp-tations 9 x 13 inch cookie sheets, which had 90 degree sharp corners, would not quite fit into its small space. But the new 11 3/4 x 11 3/4 cookies sheets - which I am reviewing here - are perfect for what I need, and can even be used on both levels of my oven at once, which speeds up everything. The only thing that I found that wasn't so nice about these new cookies sheets was that they were not quite as non-stick as the previous serving platter ... they actually needed some water on them to take off the chocolate rather than just simply wiping with a paper towel, which is all I needed with the serving platter. A small thing, but worth noting. If you have a small oven, then these cookie sheets are perfect!
So so Disappointed!
Purchased this because it looks like pieces I would definitely use. I currently own the 16 piece temptations in the same Old World blue and love it!! Thought this would be perfect as the sizes were different. WHAT a disappointment. The set looked like someone had taken a dirty blue paint cloth after all that detailed painting then rubbed in on the entire surface of the dishes then glazed it. It looked horrible and dirty and I was disappointed but, since I had the 16 piece and I knew it was not supposed to look like this, I sent it back for a replacement. Waited quite a while for a replacement then guess what!! The replacement had the same problem...I am returning for a refund this time. Not wasting my time..Disappointment in the quality!
Nice set, Poor Painting
This set is very useful! I love the set, but the paint job is very poor!!!
Beautiful set. Biscuits do not stick. However,, cookies really do stick. I still love the blue pattern.
Ceramic-ware with Character
At this price point, I think the product is good. Many reviews have expressed concerns about the painting and I agree, it appears as it is...hand painted, mass production of a low priced product. Yes, you will see the brush strokes but I think this gives the pieces "character" and you will not see two that are the same. If perfection in the art work is what you are seeking, I would not recommend. Remember, this is not the pricey stoneware so you get what you pay for. I also have some pieces in the poka-dot pattern and I think I like it better. This is my first purchase in the Old World pattern and I'm not overly enthused but the product is very practical. S & H is a bit steep...but I know this is due to the weight and not regulated by QVC.
I have recieve so many compliments on these dishes. They are great.!!!!!!!!!!!!!! No regrets on this purchase.