Rated 3.8 out of 5 by 14
Rated 5 out of 5 by PamMD Well, I like it a lot
The reviews on this top are all over the place, but it works well for me. It runs true-to-size (1X), and best of all, it is not short-waisted, as I have found many SG tops to be over the years. I'm 5'7" and it's the proper length for me, hitting me right at the hip. Yes, one can probably find less expensive cotton V-necks. But you know how it is when you're looking for one specific thing!
Rated 3 out of 5 by Shortstop88 Where's the QC for this price?
I think this tank got past quality control while they were sleeping. I hesitated paying $30+ after shipping for a tank top, but ever since A12966 (LOVED!!!) was discontinued, I've been searching for something comparable. This fabric was cheaper and the addition of the fabric trim around the neck makes it a little dowdy. But the worst part is that on all three I ordered, that little ribbon of fabric was sewn askew and that made it "lumpy". Back they went. Susan, please bring back A12966!!! The cut was very flattering and the fabric was just perfect!
Rated 3 out of 5 by pensfan98 Just not quite right
In theory the tops should work providing more coverage, but sizing was an issue. My mothers large was too big along the outside of the bust area and the material stuck out in big pockets and she wasn't a fan of the double stitching up by her neck. My 1X fit well where my mothers didn't but was too tight in the stomach area that I would be way too uncomfortable wearing it with a open shirt overtop. Bought one in every color plus one for my mom but unfortunately due to sizing they must all go back.
Rated 4 out of 5 by nc redhead Love it but the Orange is too neon
The top fits great and will hold up well. But the Orange color should be renamed HOT ORANGE. It like safety vest orange
Rated 4 out of 5 by yellow babe Way to Small
Loved this top when it was shown, received it today. Got a 1X and was to small and arm holes were to tight, Am returning today, probably should have sized up. Recommend sizing up.
Rated 4 out of 5 by giftgoddess Love the V-Neck
I bought the black in a 2X. I am 5'7" and apple shape gal who needs the V Neck fit and not form fitting. It was a little roomy, but I was afraid the 1X would have been to snug. My black color was great. The fit was almost perfect. I would definitely recommend the color, quality and fit.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Suzu great little casual tank
I think I must have about ten of these tanks. The fabric is very comfortable and soft and the cut is flattering. The v-neck is not too low. The armholes could be slightly smaller but that's not a huge issue. I wish it came in white, I could use a couple of basic white tanks made in stretch cotton. It's very hot where I live and sometimes liquid knit feels just like wearing plastic, so I need some natural fibers. Just a suggestion, Susan!!! Maybe next year, eh? And maybe hot pink, just to spice things up.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Japes I LOVE THESE TANKS!!
I read the other reviews, and don't know why they didn't work for several other customers, but I absolutely love these tanks! Have now bought multiples in every color -just wish there had been a white option. I wear these with my tennis skirts for my workouts, and with my maxi dresses - hence the multiples! The shoulder fit is fabulous -- makes my shoulders look more defined while keeping my exercise bra and regular bra straps hidden. The v-neck is not too revealing and is very flattering. Being busty, I need to show the collarbone and space between chest somewhat or I look like a marshmallow, and the length is perfect. I hope these come back next summer with 25 colors -- I would buy 50+!