Rated 4.1 out of 5 by 38
Rated 5 out of 5 by Stesan Pretty and comfortable
The material is soft, fit is good and length works for me because it's not super long plus it was on sale. I would have purchased this top even it were not sale and may pick up the teal color too. Easy to dress up or wear for casual dinner/night out. Really happy with this purchase.
Rated 4 out of 5 by otherwoman Too Big....
My fault for this return, just took a chance on the XL because the L was sold out and the XL is really too large. But the fabric is nice and soft, would have liked it in my size because all of Susan's velvets are lovely, but had to return this one, sorry. How about bringing it back next winter season??! I'd love it in red!
Rated 5 out of 5 by CheeChee Very Nice and Festive
I LOVE it. The burgundy is gorgeous, and so soft and huggable.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Sallycoop Love Susan's products, but not this one
Sadly I returned this top. It didn't fit well and was curing up at the edges with just a few minutes of wear. I didn't want to worry about how it was draping. I was sorry this wasn't an addition to my winter collection.
Rated 4 out of 5 great holiday top
This is a very versatile top for the holidays - it can be worn casual with jeans or more dressed up with a nice skirt. I bought it in wine.
It fits nicely (maybe a tad big) everyone but the neckline - which is why I gave it 4 stars. I will have to pin the neck because it's much more of a plunging neckline that I want to (or should) wear.
Rated 3 out of 5 by beverly jo Top nice - but...
The top is nice at the sale price. As another reviewer said, it's more velour than velvet. My problem with these is - I ordered 2 of them, 1 gray, 1 black, same size. The gray one fits fine, but the black one - tagged the same size - is way, way smaller. Not even close. What a pain in the neck. QVC customer service was great - no charge to return it - thank you thank you thank you. But, no, don't replace it. I don't want the aggravation. I haven't ordered from this line often, and I will not order from this line again. Too many choices out there that get it right the first time, that I can rely on. I live in the boonies and do tons of online ordering - when I find a good, reliable line, they get lots of my business. Not messing with this.
Rated 3 out of 5 by EmmyLou2 Lovely, but big
Just received this top in navy. It's well made with nice fabrication but for me, the sleeves are too long and the sizing runs big. Not going to return it, as it is now sold out in
my size in all colors. Will hem the sleeves and wear it loose. Too bad, because the accurate sizing description is of such importance when you can't try it on!
Rated 4 out of 5 by shopshop8 On the Fence
I really wanted a velvet top in burgundy for a couple of Holiday dinner parties I will be attending and this seemed to fit the bill. Even though I wish the fabric had less of a velour texture, it is still nice and the color is good. The neck is good for necklaces. The fit is the part I am not sure about. It is nice until you get to the side that does not wrap. The pleats pucker and create an awkward bulk but only in one little section. I hate to send back because the higher end department stores have slim pickings this year, offer mainly just black pieces, and were at the very least twice the price. I have to ask myself if I would have bought it if I got to try it on in the store first.
Rated 3 out of 5 by AGL more velour like than velvel
I'm a Susan Graver fan. That said, this top missed the mark for me. The velvet felt more like velour and it just didn't have that holiday 'zing' I had hoped for. It was more a blah. It's getting returned. I'll give the tunic a try...because...I'm loyal to Susan! It's rare she strikes out like this...check my closet! :")
Rated 3 out of 5 by zannee33 Sized down
I always size down on SG tops. They are always 1 size too big one me. ALWAYS. So I went down from a Large to a Med. That being said I really wanted to like this top. The color and fabric are beautiful. But the V neck was way too plunging for me. I would have had to pin the neck closed. There was also too much fabric at the bottom of the blouse where the overlap is. This created a bulky, odd extra fabric on my tummy area. Not flattering. So it went back.
Rated 3 out of 5 by summerscottage It didn't fit me, but it was nice.
I'm not a huge fan of SG stuff - she's entertaining but her clothes seem more mature. But this was something I was looking for. Unfortunately, the fit wasn't what I was hoping for - I guess I was hoping it would fit in a top version of the Lauren dresses with all the ruching. It doesn't. The XS was too long and too big in the chest. The XXS was too small in the shoulders and arms. It just didn't look great.
Rated 3 out of 5 by catlady414 Tried to Like the Look
I wanted so much for this top to work for me. I bought it in the wine which matches the Susan Graver velvet skirt I bought last year. Color was a perfect match. I ordered the large (I am usually a medium in SG tops), The fit was fine however the fabric and color really accentuated my middle and made me look wide. Tried it on with velvet pants also and still the same. I have other velvet tops (twin set from SG) that do not do that. Also, like other reviewers it could use a hook and eye closure for modesty.
Sorry to say it's being returned.