Rated 3.5 out of 5 by 20
Rated 1 out of 5 by HollyBeth So Disappointed In This One...
I have a closet full of Susan Graver tops but have stopped buying because her styles seem to be becoming very matronly lately and sizing is very inconsistent. But when I saw this top, I knew I had to have it. I mean, how could you go wrong with pretty much a basic top with a little frill down the front? I ordered the black and after reading the reviews on it and how tight some were saying it was, I got it in a medium. HUGE mistake!! I received it the day before yesterday and it went back yesterday. The color was a good, deep black and the little ruffle was cute. I didn't mind the ruffle not being hemmed because it lays in such a way that it almost has to be left unhemmed. My problem was, the top was way too big so it was very unflattering and it was too long. I know Susan likes to make her tops long but this one hits you at a point, on your bottom, where it actually makes you look like you are flat all the way down your backside. Yes, unflattering, to say the least. The top looked frumpy and matronly. Almost like a top you would see on a little old woman at a funeral. Not trying to be rude, just stating facts. I thought this top would be flirty and even a little sexy with my palazzo pants but it fell WAY short from that look. The flutter sleeves were cut very sloppily and, as one review said, they looked like they had been cut with dull scissors. If you held a sleeve at the seam, they weren't even. It looked like someone just grabbed scissors and cut! This top could be great IF: it was a couple of inches shorter, had side slits to make it modern and the laser cut sleeves were even and straight. As it is now, it's not worth $45. Sorry.
Rated 4 out of 5 by smokerinterest Nice Top
I ordered the Xlg because large was not available. It runs bigger than other Xlg
tops that I've purchased. That being said, it is very pretty and comfortable. I might
just have to take it in a bit. I wish that Susan would continue making the other liquid
knit tops without the "frill" in front. I've purchased 4 of those in the past. Can you bring
those back -- also, much cheaper than this top! thanks.
Rated 1 out of 5 by champion-shopper Sizing Is Off Again!
I have never seen a line of clothing where the sizing is so off! I ordered 6 Susan Graver liquid knit tops in the same size that I always take. One was huge and the others were too small.
Why the inconsistancy?! There needs to be more quality control especially since the price of these liquid knit pieces have soared since their inception. It's hard to get any quality control on pieces not made in the USA.
Having said all that, the liquid knit pieces are great and wash well. It's just a shame the sizing is so bad and that because of something that is not in the customers control, we have to pay to send it back!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Florida_Girl Beautiful Blouse
I'm not usually into ruffles because of my full bust but I loved this blouse so much I came back for all the colors. Very feminine and comfortable! Goes well with so many things in my wardrobe from dress pants and skirts to jeans and shorts. Susan PLEASE consider doing this same style blouse in platinum gray, chocolate brown, purple, and a crisp white.
Rated 1 out of 5 by paeee NOT FINISHED
I like this shirt, but the sleeves and ruffles are unfinished. The material is cut and the raw edges show. For the price all seams should be finished!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by QVCfaninIowa Definitely a Keeper
Another beauty from Susan Graver! It's a perfect fit and I love the longer length to hide the "tummy" issues. I bought the blue and the color is gorgeous. It comes out of the washer and dryer without a single wrinkle.......ready to wear! This will be going on my next trip with me, for sure! Can be dressed up or down......great with capris or dress slacks. Thank you, Susan!! It's a hit with me!
Rated 2 out of 5 by still29 Disappointing Hems
While the hosts touted the cut edge of sleeves and ruffle as trendy, to me they looked cheap. I love the 'no wrinkle, no stain' and wear-ability of SG's clothes. I have a closet full but this one had to go back. Could find equal or better at WM. Please don't make me have to start shopping at the mall again!
Awhile back I ordered two of SG's patterned see-through long-sleeved tops to go over tanks. The seams on those were not fully sewn together. I've never had any issue with the sewing on any SG pieces before. On one, the button placket was not sewn down top to bottom but had a big gap where the seam missed one side. On the other, a sleeve was not fully sewn in. Is all this an effort to cut corners? I hope not. I didn't see the flaws until I put them on and I didn't wear these until the 30 day return period was past so off to the local seamstress I went. What a pain..
Rated 5 out of 5 by Verified Reviewer So flattering
The ruffle edges on this top are laser cut on the bias. If they were hemmed, it would lay goofy, look terrible, and the ruffles wouldn't float and drape so beautifully. It's not a design or production error.
I have two, and I love them!