Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 19
Rated 5 out of 5 by cottonjenn Love this top
Ok I just received this sweater today from a wait list order and love it. I'm in my sixties, wear a size M or 10-12, I'm 5' 1 1/2. I usually order a M and 98% of what I purchase fits, the 2% that doesn't is because of my body. When I ordered this top the M wasn't available, only the XS/S was. Reading reviews on how the top fits I decided to give the XS/S a shot. Then on confirmations the size read XXS/S and now I panicked thinking it might not fit, it might be snug in the hips. Well, it fit as expected. It's loose like it's shown. A larger size would have been way too big. So even though this is big, it's the big that was expected. The material is a nice light weight. So glad the smaller size worked.
Rated 3 out of 5 by adoptshelterpets Not as expected
This sweater was not as expected. It is very thin and some women may want to wear a cami underneath. I ordered the pink and it is very pale pink. It is also very long. I didn't feel it is worth the price.
Rated 2 out of 5 by beanie50 Size Down
I know this is supposed to be oversized, but when I put it on, it fell right to the floor, would not even stay on my shoulders. I always wear a L or XL in Susan's fashions and I like my tops loose not fitted. I ordered the M-L size and it should have been fine. It did not even work for my friend who wears a 1X and also likes her tops loose. I loved the sweater, especially the material. I gave it two stars because of sizing issue. Sizing has gotten to be a big issue, I have to return more than I can keep. I tried to reorder in smaller size but not available. It looked great on all the models, it would be nice if they would have said what size they were wearing. I'm willing to bet they had to size down.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Oliviamen Loved It!
Great sweater, it was much more than I expected very soft very comfortable I could just live in it!
Rated 5 out of 5 by kct Home Run for Susan Graver
Yes, this sweater is oversized -- the presentation makes clear that it is designed along the lines of a poncho. I ordered by regular size, and the fit is perfect in the neck, shoulders and arms, while the body of the garment is very loose and flowing. If you look at the models and even at Susan in the video, you can see that this was the fashion intent. It is a good length, and the weight and colors will transition into Spring. This piece seems to be somewhat outside of the normal Susan Graver "box," and she really hit it out of the park; I look forward to seeing what she comes up with next!
Rated 4 out of 5 by Kar4U Enjoying This Oversized Sweater
I don't purchase a lot of SG items, as I am not a huge fan of her designs or material. I thought I would take a try on this sweater. I like it, it's oversize and comfortable. It is thin, but I like that, others may not. I will try a few other things I have seen and try them as I haven't bought anything from her in ages.
Rated 5 out of 5 by lessizmore My FAVORITE SG knit
Love the flow and drape of this sweater. And at 5'10" it is just long enough for me. Soft and comfy and stylish in so many situations. Versatile. Now that we have an actual winter, I think I would wear it every day if I could. Talk about effortless dressing.
Rated 1 out of 5 by chatterbox huge boxy fit with NO SHAPE
this is supposed to be a big baggy look but it is ridiculously huge. It just hangs on your body. My husband said it looks like I'm wearing a sail. That says it all - NO SHAPE. Colors are pretty and soft but fit awful and the fabric is inexpensive. I think you could buy at any basic department store for $29.99