Rated 2 out of 5 by 21
Rated 1 out of 5 by nanapudding Disappointed
Ordered this for New Year's Eve. Followed the vague cooking instructions....
end up with an overcooked, tough Prime rib.
Had to turn into very expensive taco meat so that we didn't waste it. :(
Rated 5 out of 5 by erniep Best prime rib
I was really reluctant about cooking this for Christmas after reading some of these reviews. I ordered the red wine prime rib and it was one of the best I have ever eaten. Prime rib has fat but it was minimal. I have ordered prime rib from other companies on QVC and it does not compare. Will order again.
Rated 1 out of 5 by algin Awful
My husband and I have a prime rib every New Years Eve. This year we decided to try Rastelli's...big mistake. It was the worst we have ever had...fatty, tough and with lots of gristle. If there was a yuk rating choice, that's what I would have chosen. One star is too good for it. If our dog was still alive, he may have been willing to eat it...that is if he could have worked his way through the gristle without choking. Total waste of money.
Rated 1 out of 5 by zeirdreck Worst beef prime rib, ever.
I purchased this roast for our Christmas dinner and I was so disappointed with this product. I have always in the past purchased my prime rib roast from Costco and this year I decided to try this for convenience sake because I always in the past have had to travel by ferry boat to the mainland to reach Costco for my purchase. I now know that the inconvenience of traveling to Costco is so worth the trip....their prime meat is far superior to your product. I am sorry to say, I will never purchase this product again. My Christmas dinner was ruined because of this black angus prime rib roast.
Rated 1 out of 5 by QVCer- NH Deeply disappointing!
Dry and tough! One sour note on a otherwise lovely Christmas. Never again!
Rated 1 out of 5 by Gerburn Rastelli First and Last Timer!
Very disappointed was looking forward to this and in the end this was a Choice Rib Roast at best you missed the Prime Grade Rastelli's! I can buy better local and alot cheaper also.
Rated 1 out of 5 by SInbadsgirl "STEER" CLEAR OF THIS!!!!
I, too, purchased this to have for my Christmas dinner. I was so embarrassed. The roast was fatty, gristly and had absolutely no taste. QVC needs to part company with Rastelli. It's a very bad reflection on QVC. Please "steer" clear of this company and their products.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Verified Reviewer TOO TOUGH FOR AN ELECTRIC KNIFE!
I cooked and served this roast for Christmas Eve as a late dinner for my family. When I started to slice the meat, after resting it for 30 min., the electric knife would not go through an area of gristle beneath the layer of fat. There was also an excessive amount of fat on the roast too. I asked my nephew to come and slice the meat and he also had trouble with this roast. It was so tough my sister could not chew it. I have bought several KC prime rib roasts before and never had any trouble. KC roast were not listed in the size I wanted when I made this purchase. Never again will I use this brand. So very embarrassing. I will apply for a refund. I could have done better at my local grocery store.