Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 14
Rated 2 out of 5 by Shine Green edging not lined up well
I love Winterberry, but the green along the edges of 2 of the 4 plates in this set is not consistently applied to follow the curves on the plates. If I had purchased them in a store rather than online, I would have returned them.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Penny08 Perfect size for small meal.
They are the perfect size for a sandwich and chips or cake and ice cream. I use this pattern all year.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Diane3 Replacement issue
Ordered 16 dishes in preparation for next Christmas. One dish in order was chipped. Company immediately sent replacement. Upon receipt, quickly realized that replacement dish did not really match the other 15 received 2 weeks prior (coloring & size of plate). Per the company, they have different manufacturing plants & the boxes all get co-mingled when sent to their warehouse. In short, no way for them to guarantee dishes from same plant. Can't figure out why each plant has a slightly different mold. Very disappointing! Returned the plates!
Rated 1 out of 5 by JoJo10 Green edge trim not positioned correctly on salad plate.
The green trim edge on the salad plate is too low. It is placed on the side of the plate or slightly below the edge.I bought four plates to complete my collection. They didn't match my previous plates. I am not satisfied and I don't think I will make any purchase from them in the future.
Rated 5 out of 5 by jmmc Pfaltzgraff quality
A little disappointed as the plates are smaller than what I have. I can't locate the 9" plates. Also pfaltzgraff is over priced.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Truly27 Not the same
I have a set that I was trying to complete so purchased additional pieces. Well, if you are trying to match your older winterberry with the new stuff, forget it. The color is different: Mine is very bright white and when the new stuff is placed next to it the new pieces have a yellow tinge, the salad plates are not footed, they are thinner, and the glaze does not hold up as well. I am very disappointed in the product decline. If you are buying all new you won't notice the poor quality but when compared to the older pieces the new ones seem very cheap.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sally1955 Lovely dessert plates
I bought six of these plates - four plus two extra - to go with a tea set. They are lovely dessert or cookie plates. Highly recommended.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Ds1223 Beautiful dessert plates
After hosting my family Christmas, I resolved to never serve dessert on paper plates again. I ordered these after the holiday festivities were over and can't wait to use them next Christmas. After scanning many websites, I chose this pattern and am more than pleased.