Rated 3.5 out of 5 by 123
Rated 5 out of 5 by kydarling Nothing Better!!!
This is the best product I have ever used stays on and doesn't run easy applied please bring back the 10 pack assortment! It was in a round green snakeskin tube .
Rated 5 out of 5 by catmd A staple
I wouldn't be without this eye liner. It truly is soft enough to line the inner rim, and not tug at my eyelid. It has staying power. No flaking. I've tried many but I keep going back to this, in black. It is a classic staple. The five pack is a really good deal, too.
This and Mallys mascara prove themselves time and again to be my all time faves.
Rated 1 out of 5 by grmmel Disappointed
This product did not work for me like demonstrated on air. The host rubbed her hand repeatedly showing the product would not rub off and that is absolutely not how this product worked for me. She also made quite a note of the fact that she had designed the sharpener that came with the product. This was a very flimsy plastic sharpener that was not unlike one from the dollar store. This was my first purchase of a product from this line and I will be skeptical going forward. Returning today.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Peachyme Did not like
Did not live up to expectation of water proof. My eyes started to water ,but the eye liner ran And I had a messy eyes.
Rated 5 out of 5 by JZehn Great Product
Thank You, Thank You Mally for putting this kit together. Love the liner, goes on easy and stays on! Don"t retire this kit!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Jacquee Great eyeliner
Love this eyeliner goes on so easy and stays were you put it till you take it off. Best I've ever bought
Rated 5 out of 5 by sweetjeannie Mally's Most Wanted 5pc Starlight Eyeliner
I love how smoothly the eyeliner pencil goes on my eyelids; no tugging or pulling on my 71 yr old eyelids. I love the chocolate brown color for my hazel eyes. Thank you Mally for a great eyeliner pencil. I am glad I purchased 5 eyeliner pencils when they were on more easy pays.
Rated 1 out of 5 by nobleridge DOES NOT STAY ON.
I AGREE WITH THE REVIEWS WHO SAY IT SMEARS AND DOESN'T STAY ON ALL DAY.
THE ONLY THING I LIKE ABOUT THESE LINERS THEY DON'T BURN THE INSIDES OF MY EYES. KORRES ON HSN IS THE ONLY LINERS THAT WORK FOR ME. GOING BACK TO KORRES. SENDING THESE BACK. NO MORE MALLY FOR ME.