Rated 1.8 out of 5 by 10
Rated 5 out of 5 by gabbib LOVEEEEEE
I don't know what mascara some of these ladies used but I've had no problems with Mally Waterproof!! I actually leave makeup remover on a lil longer to get all of it off. I LOVE this mascara. I like the other one also but this one is my fav!! Don't stop making it Mally please. My daughter and have had NO problems!!!
Rated 1 out of 5 by Fluffychick RACCOON EYES
I am sorry that I ordered this mascara. In less than an hour of wear, this mascara bleeds down below my eyes and I look like I need a complete face wash. I'm also sorry that there were two of them in the package. I've never returned this kind of a product, but I think I just may do that with this.
Rated 1 out of 5 by JuJuBeanCali Dried Out Products Received
Usually these are my favorite mascaras, But when they came to my house and I opened the packages both of them were dried up and dried out and I was really shocked and disappointed. I will stick to buying them at my local Ulta store where they are fresh and not expired
Rated 1 out of 5 by QVC247 Waterproof...not
So disappointed with this product. Goes on nicely, but it is not at all waterproof. Smudges within the first few hours of application, and is practically gone by the sixth hour.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Jerseygirl213 What Happened ?
Mallys Waterproof Mascara that came in the silver tube was the BEST ever! This is terrible.. it smears but its also very hard to get off even with my purity... so very disappointed.. I want the old Mascara back!!
Rated 1 out of 5 by drdel Not Good Any More
What happen to the quality. Not good any more .when you first came out. The product was great .so sad to see a great product to go bad. Pleas bring back the quality of the product again .such a shame to lose the quality
Rated 1 out of 5 by DIANES not so good anymore
So sorry to say the mascara is not the same MALLY please fix the problem. When I first purchased it ,IT WAS BULLETPROOF! Now it is gummy and smears. This was the best I had ever tried and I need it back the way is was! THANK YOU PLEASE FIX!
Rated 1 out of 5 by Horsesrock I agree!
" What happened to the most perfect WP mascara EVER made?? Was soooo excited to see it come back...ordered it immediately....very timely shipping...but it is not the same as Mally's previous company. It never dries...stays somewhat sticky...does not lengthen at all...the tip of the brush is flat...and most importantly, it does not hold the curl in my stick straight lashes. With her previous WP mascara, I'd curl my lashes...1-2 coats of the mascara...and I was good for the day.. Now it does not stay curled beyond 2 minutes!! It does come off easily with a remover. And now on for the miserable search for a new WP mascara....sigh "