Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 2280
Rated 5 out of 5 by CristelRV In Love
I have fallen in love with this mascara! After using this I can never go back to my drug store mascara. Even higher end mascaras flake and tighten my skin. With one sweep of this, my lashes look thicker and longer! The best part is how soft my lashes feel! I don't feel like I have pins and needles for lashes after using this product! Recommend recommend!
Rated 2 out of 5 by Marmaduke66 Something has changed.
I have used this mascara for years and loved it. Gave it for Christmas presents and told my family and friends how great it was. Was. That's the key word. The last two tubes have been very gloppy and overloaded on the brush and the tip. It's like the rubber at the top of the tube isn't working properly and not removing the excess off the brush. I'm not sure why, but it isn't the same; so I'm looking for another mascara.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Ignasiak Love/Hate Relationship
I have loved this mascara for many years now. I have to admit the first time I tried it I didn't like it because it clumped. Months later I ordered more & tried it again. I absolutely loved it & have been using it for years! What has happened to my beloved mascara? It's dried out & the brush seems different. Everything that I loved about this mascara has changed. Where once it built beautiful lashes so easily, has turned into a difficult task & then it flakes off throughout the day. Please Mally, return your former formula & brush so I can remain a loyal fan. Thank you!!
Rated 2 out of 5 by Kathehman Too gloppy!
I liked the mascara, except that it gets Very gloppy and loaded at the end of the brush. It, then, puts too much mascara on the outside lashes. It's hard to de-clump them. It's just too messy!
Rated 2 out of 5 by elizapt Something has changed
I'm so glad to read from other reviewers that they, too, feel like this mascara has changed. I thought it was just me. I have been using this for years but the last two I ordered were terrible: clumpy, clumpy, clumpy. I have ordered the 6 in a box and they were all just fine but not these last two. I'm sorry to say I'm going to try something else. Are Mally's products old or has the formula been changed?
Rated 5 out of 5 by Miss Ashley The Best!
Love Mally's mascara it's the best! Love it I only buy and use it! Goes on great just need two coats on the top. Lasts all day!
Rated 5 out of 5 by pwf Great Mascara
This is the best mascara I've ever used. It makes my lashes look so much fuller and longer.
Rated 3 out of 5 by likexotics used to be the best
This used to be the best...I am in need of mascara and just don't know what to buy anymore... Last time I bought this when I got six of them... Half were already dried up....Mally please look into this!! This is my favorite when the tubes are full!
Rated 2 out of 5 by Bobbesock Packaging is faulty
Each time I have purchased, has a faulty tube. After about the fourth use, the mascara comes out of the tube, getting the outside of the tube full of mascara. And I am not a mascara "pumper". What a waste! I like the mascara, not the packaging.
Rated 5 out of 5 by steph71 Best Mascara I Have Ever Used!
Not to thick. .not to runny..
Great consistency! Really made my lashes stand out.
Rated 2 out of 5 by lisamdee Great When Not Old
I have a love/hate relationship with this mascara. When it's like it's supposed to be it's the best mascara I have ever used and I've probably tried every high end mascara out there and this is the best. Unfortunately more often than not, I get an old tube that's practically dried up. I ordered the package of six and three were dried up. Another kit I ordered all of them were old. Mally please do a better job with quality control as I have wasted a bunch of money over the last few years and will likely use another mascara due to it being so difficult to get one that is fresh. This is TEN star product when it's like it's supposed to be but I can't give a five star with the inconsistency.
Rated 1 out of 5 by browta Worst Than $ Store Brand
This mascara is clumpy straight out of the tube. Close your eyes and you have mascara above and below your eyes.. Very disappointed!!!!! Love Mally products!!! Not this one. Back to cover girl for me.