Rated 3.9 out of 5 by 2345
Rated 3 out of 5 by Heidired Clumps
I was impressed by the presentation, but this did not work for me. Clumps at times and seems very thick..
Rated 2 out of 5 by RachelrooZ Raccoon eyes
If you are using an oil-based make-up, you'll get quite bad raccoon eyes underneath.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Steph C Used To Love This
The last several times I've ordered this mascara, only one of the tubes was usable. The second tube has been a clumpy mess. Won't be re-ordering.
Rated 1 out of 5 by LMJgolfer What happened to a good product?
What has happened to this mascara? I have been a fan of Mallys for a long time but this will be the last time I will order this mascara. The brush feels like a brillo pad on my lashes! Hurts to apply. And it is clumpy & cakes. You know the saying "a good thing never lasts" well here is one of them. This was my second order that has been of poor quality. My Cover Girl in a pinch works better for less $!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Susanbaj Great Lashes!
I have been using this product for about two years, and it is fantastic! Over the last five years I've had a lot of chemo and lost my hair twice, along with most of my lashes and brows. The lashes did come back, and I started using this with great results. I always get compliments on my lashes...the dermatologist and eye doctor even asked if I use Latisse! Also, I used to use an eyelash curler every day, but don't have to with Mally's mascara.
Rated 1 out of 5 by SantanaShopper Not what it used to be
I have to agree with alot of the recent Auto delivery people on here. Ive been on AD for years with this mascara. I love love love it. But now my last 2 shipments have been horrible. Used one tube twice and couldn't do it anymore. They looked horrible and I have long naturally curled lashes. Tried out the other and it was the same. Never had a problem before but now I'm worried all the next shipments will be just as bad. Fingers crossed because I don't want to going mascara shopping again.
Rated 1 out of 5 by t2steve Did the Formula Change?
I have been receiving this mascara on auto delivery for several years. I loved it. I would curl my eyelashes and then apply this mascara and it didn't weigh down my lashes like some mascaras. It made them thick and long. However, the last two auto shipments I've received seem to be a different formula. When I first opened the tube the mascara was clumpy on the brush. I thought maybe I had received an old tube, so I opened the other one and it was the same way. I threw them both away. Now I have received my next auto shipment and they are the same way. I am cancelling my auto delivery. Bring back the old formulation.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Q- Girl What Happened!!!
I have been getting this product for a long time and lately everything is different. It's thin and can't apply well. Mally why would you change a great product. It's just terrible. I'm canceling my auto delivery.
Rated 1 out of 5 by lillylady Too Clumpy
Too thick and clumpy. When you close up the mascara, it gets all over the tube. I will not be buying this again. Sorry Mally!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Lina05 Love it
I love Mally beauty products! The mascara is just one of her products that I have. It makes my eyelashes look great. My mother loves it too so that why I ordered the duo. Thanks Mally :)
Rated 5 out of 5 by Texas is Fabulous Best mascara I've found!
Mally's mascara doesn't flake or run, and it is absolutely bullet proof. I can even wear it on my bottom lashes in the Houston humidity, and it won't smudge under my eyes. I don't waste time with any others!
Rated 1 out of 5 by Bzp Mally Volumizing mascara
This Mascara is not what Mally claims. It DOES NOT give you the lengthy lashes shown on the show. I have used it, put on numerous coats (Mally says apply 2 coats) and it does not make them as long as they show on TV and the more coats you put on to try to lengthen, the clumpier it gets. Yes, It also DOES flake off and causes eye irritation. I was very disappointed. I have worked as a make up artist for Clinique and MAC and have to laugh when watching Mally on QVC. When she demo's product, you can tell she barely touches the model with the product. The bullet proof swipe.. you can tell she is cupping her hand and not fully rubbing as she claims. I have tried the test myself and the product smears all over my hand. None of what she claims is true. I have tried many products from her face defender to lip glosses to foundation to mascara. I just wonder who all these celebrity clients really are...very disappointed. Will not buy anymore.