Rated 3.8 out of 5 by 2444
Rated 5 out of 5 by toobusy4retail My Favorite Mascara !!
I've been using this mascara a few years now and it's still my favorite. I occasionally try other brands but this is by far my favorite. I wear contact lenses and have sensitive eyes. This mascara never irritates my eyes, it stays on all day with no smudging or fallout. My Dearest Mally ....Please, Please bring back the 6 pack of mascara I feel like I'm running out if I only have a couple. Mascara hoarder ...Yep!
Rated 2 out of 5 by BSurLife65 Too Dry/Old?
Should have returned this but it took over 30 days to notice that the usually awesome Mally mascara was drying out & clumping on the brush. So I apply it lightly to the ends of my lashes and check for clumps. Time to switch to another brand. DISAPPOINTED.
Rated 5 out of 5 by katie in venice my favorite
i can not use any other mascara then mally's , especially this one. i have tried others but for me this is the best. it applies just right and does not smudge or rub off. the best.
Rated 1 out of 5 by S Kasper That's a First
This is my first QVC review and the first time I've been disappointed in a Mally purchase. I LOVE her line of makeup BUT boy am I disappointed with my recent order of mascara. I ended up tossing the receipt and packaging because I never thought I would be let down by this mascara, otherwise I would be returning it. I've ordered it a half dozen times before but there must be a new formula because this stuff was absolute junk. It's clumpy and sticky and definitely not the same texture. I would compare it to the cheap stuff you can get at any drug store :( Mally, girl, what happened? I was so happy with the old mascara but now you left me looking for a new brand.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Spitzy22 Sludge
Like sludge in a tube. I used to love this. What happened? I re-purchased thinking I got a bad batch, still got sludge.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Gidget-98233 Worst purchase in a long time!
Wow, has this changed...and not for the better. I used this years ago and recently purchased a new one. It was not even remotely similar to what I used to buy. This tube seems to be almost dried out already (I only opened it today) and it took forever to get any coverage on my lashes. I always curl my lashes prior to application and I would swear it took all the curl out. I have had it on for only 4 hours and most of it is now gone :( which is really unfortunate since I still have 4 more hours of work left and now I look like I have 2 black eyes!
Absolutely the WORST purchase I have made in a long time. I am going back to Better Than S#x mascara for sure!
Rated 1 out of 5 by muslkarz Old product?
I've been using this for years and loved it. But this last shipment was terrible. It's clumpy and dry and not at all what it used to be. I'll be sending it back. I'm sad that after so many years I need to find another "perfect" mascara. I'm upset that I also have to pay to return it when it's obviously not the same formula as I've been accustomed to receiving.
You let me down Mally.
Rated 1 out of 5 by babee oh the former reviewer are right on
Not the same mascara. I tried it. hated it. and compared it to an old one. definitely not the same. sending it back.