Rated 3.2 out of 5 by 18
Rated 1 out of 5 by 21d26 faulty product
The product tugs at eyelids. When I sharpened it, the eyeliner in the middle fell out completely
Rated 5 out of 5 by Phoebe57 Love This Eyeliner!
I was concerned that the eyeliner end is chubby, but I decided to try it. I wear contact lenses so I have to have water proof. It gets between my lashes and makes them look super thick. I don't even wear mascara all the time any more. The best!
Rated 2 out of 5 by TPCT Flawed Design
The shadow stick falls out. Mally, just stick with the Starlight duos and NOT the double ended duos! Please bring back Lucky Penny!!
Rated 1 out of 5 by goodgrief1 COLOR STICK BROKE
Used it once, gently, and the color stick broke off!
Rated 1 out of 5 by Geigei Never Got to Use
I purchased this and did not get around to using it till well after the 30 day return policy, instead of the problem others appear to be having with the shadow stick falling out, mine has fallen into the outer pencil and is stuck below the surface, I have shaken it, left it standing upside down, all to no avail. Sadly a color I was really wanting to try. I love Mally's line, I am faithful to a number of her products and have introduced the line to many friends but this is my first disappointment.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Marilyn J MALLY, HELP!!!!
I really love the color Glitzy and need it, however on each purchase the inner crayon has fallen out and then dries out, even though I have put it back in and kept the lid capped. I then have taken the inner crayon out after it has become dry and smash it up and mix with alcohol. This I store in a container. When I put it on my lid, it is blotchy, but works somewhat.
This is a $20 dollar eye shadow pencil. It really should work better than it does.
Mally, can you do something about this? I love the Glitzy color, and haven't been able to find a similar color even though I have tried many other brands.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Scottiesforme Issue
I love the color, I love the staying power, however...the color "stick" keeps falling out of the pencil. This happened the first time I used it and I haven't sharpened it yet. I love it but the color falling out of the pencil all the time is a pain.
Rated 1 out of 5 by mickl I'm conflicted
Love the way the product goes on - and how it looks on. However, it does not have more that what you see in the tip. It's a very small amount of product for the price - or what one would expect to get in a delivery system like this. If there had been more product inside I would have given it a 5 star rating for sure! Love the look and feel enough to buy another one at some point - but will use very sparingly and not as a daily tool. That's a shame.