A218001 - Mally Eye Amplifying Shadow Liner Duo with Sharpener
Perfect - Just Like the Evercolor Shadow Sticks
I can't live without the Evercolor Shadow Sticks so I had to try these, especially that great cobalt color. The dark taupe that came with it is a dupe for the shadow stick in twilight, which is great because that's one of my staple eyeshadows so I will definitely use it up.
My verdict is that they are exactly the same PERFECT formula as the shadow sticks, bulletproof and they set properly, which is difficult to find in a cream shadow. You truly don't need or want to use any primer with this. Glide on, smudge and done. I see why Mally created this new delivery format though, to capitalize more on the "shadow liner" trend since these are sharpenable - so you can get more precision than with the shadow sticks if you want to use it as a liner.
Another wonderful product Mally, thank you so much!
I purchased the "bulletproof" eyeshadow because my shadow tends to migrate throughout the day and end up in the crease of my eyelid. I like the color that I ordered...but it was far from "bulletproof". It didn't even last a full 10 hours (my workshift) so by the time I got home, it was faded and settled in the old familiar crease. For short periods of time it did seem to last, but definitely NOT as long as Mally brags.
I love them!!
I have just one in the chestnut, and am ordering the Purple set. They do stay on, despite what some have said. They go on nice and creamy, but do set up, so they stay on. My only complaint would be, if we have to order two, I would prefer to pick my own colors singularly. That would be perfect. I have several of the Mally products, and I think they are great!!
Exactly What I was Looking For!!!!
I am now a "Mally" believer. I was only looking for an eye liner in this color palette of rich and shimmering colors, but I got more, a lot more. I got lasting wear and sensational color effects that play so well with my eye shadows collection. Love them so very much. I am definitely ordering more to pile stock, just in case. I do not want to see my self with out them.
first and last
I purchased this product a few months ago and was very disappointed..it does not stay on. It disappears within minutes....you can't even see it..will trash it.
MALLY DOES IT AGAIN!
I got the cobalt set and have also ordered another one in chestnut that I love. These are a nice switch from powders and I had no problem with them lasting all day! I like the color selection and they are very practical. Thanks!
I recently purchased Mally's 5 piece waterproof eyeliner set and fell in love with the copper penny shade. I have been searching for that precise shade for a very long time.... Anyway, I thought I would give these a try and boy... am I happy that I did. Honestly, I cannot believe how fantastic they are. Staying power is fantastic and application is beyond simple. No more trouble with powder going everywhere. No more application and reapplication of the powder for depth. These rock. Anyone having trouble with this product should look to the possible culprit; namely, oil based primers, eye creams. using the wrong primer, and/or using a face concealer or foundation as a primer. These things will break everything down. I am planning a trip to England next month and you can bet your bottom dollar I'll be bringing ONLY these. Thanks Mally!
Sorry Mally....Not bullet proof
I had purchased another brand of creamy color eyeliners (that starts with T and ends with E) but they did not have a blue....so I tried Mally. No comparison. Much less color depth and they do not stay on. Sorry to say. Love Mally but they don't have the rich depth of color and stay-abilility they're advertised to have.
I absolutely love, love this product! Colors are fabulous.....great option to eyeliner pencil plus shadow, of course...I use the deep taupe to shadow and the cobalt blue to line top and bottom = no harsh look, just beautiful and a little smokey.
Not bullet proof for all
I purchased malley several years ago and it was ok but not bullet proof. I tried it again thinking I would have a better outcome. The eyeliner smeared off within 4 to 5 hours and the mascara drooped as well.? It simply does not work on all skin types,
eye shadow is pretty
I got this yesterday and it was the wrong color from what i ordered but it was my second choose so i kept it and it is very pretty
The Eye's have it!
Stays on all day! Goes on super smooth, beautiful colors. The color are perfect for my skin tone. Mally makes the best products.