Rated 3.7 out of 5 by 72
Rated 2 out of 5 by BluBirdGirl Difficult to apply
I found this to be too dry and hard for a good application. I got the dark taupe and it's a great color but I can't apply it evenly because it tugs and drags. I will return.
Rated 5 out of 5 by shayna The BEST!!
Please keep selling this!!! The best eyeliner I've ever used!
Rated 1 out of 5 by fireworks in florida NEARLY IMPOSSIBLE TO REMOVE !!
not the same formulation as it used to be --- and nearly impossible to remove from the eye at the end of the day. Sending Back --- quality is not the same -- Lucky Penny was always a favorite -- not this time --- poor quality.
Rated 5 out of 5 by cjjs Products? Thin eyeliner...
Have used Mally automatic eyeliner and her thin automatic liners for years, they truly are there best . Stay all day go on well. I came to reorder there 2 piece set of black automatic thin eyeliner sticks an see 1. They are not listed and also her line has shunk. Is she being closed out? Have noticed similar with Liz Claiborne, but I digress..... Her city chick palates were great as well. Very disappointed that products that are the work horse are disappearing. I haven't seen this liner at the big box store either. Happens to frequently......now what right...
Rated 3 out of 5 by redrubyslippers Where is dark brown????
I love this eyeliner--received compliments when wearing it also. BUT! What happened to the ever popular dark brown?? That is what I always wore, and now I can't find it anywhere. I have also heard other women with the same complaint. I do not like sparkle in my eyeliner, and I do not like soft brown either. MALLY! PLEASE bring that dark brown back!!! I do not like to have to sharpen my eyeliner--this is why I LOVE this one. If you still had the dark brown, I would have given 5 stars to this! But now I do not buy any.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Christmas Queen Disappointed
I purchased this because I like to line my ninner rim..top and bottom. This was advertised to be good for it. I went to a wedding and cried, of course. Well....I had raccoon eyes...the bottom rim ran all over the place. I wasn't aware until someone told me. It was embarrassing.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Walter Love this in my color.
This is a great eye liner. Cannot live without it and have ordered it for years. It's great if you have problems putting on eye liner as its easier. It stays on and goes on smoothly.
The only problem this time is I cannot find my usual onyx color. Where is onyx? And please, please bring back the duo. But I HAVE to have onyx! Please Mally, I need onyx!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sarky49 Still The Best
This is the only liner that really is bulletproof. It stays on all day, no matter what. It even stays on through tears, watery eyes, and a shower. I like this one because you don't need a sharpener.