Rated 3.2 out of 5 by 33
Rated 3 out of 5 by beckyf7 Stay power as presented but
Although stays on until you take it off, there is very little product....breaks off pencil or doesn't come out at all. If this is resolved, would highly recommend.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Mambo Waterproof eyeliner
This product advertised on QVC stated that it would not come off until one decided to take it off. It was also stated that it didn't matter if lids tended to be oily or dry. It would stay on.I volunteer in a school from 7:00AM until 12:30AM three days a week. By the time I leave school most of the eyeliner is gone. This morning I applied it at 7:30 AM And went to Sunday School and church. Arrived home at 12:30 and there was no trace. Very disappointed with this product. It is no better than grocery store products. Will avoid this brand in the future. Did anyone at QVC try it before trying to sell it? Too much trouble to return , but learned a lesson. Be careful of sales pitches!
Rated 5 out of 5 by CJA Love!
This has been the best eyeliner I've ever purchased. It stays put and I don't get racoon eyes by the middle of the afternoon. Purchased this product over and over again. The pencil lasts a long time too despite it's size.
Rated 1 out of 5 by UMS Not Worth The Money
Only lasts about 2 hours. The product does not roll up, sent first one back, second one does not roll up either. Sending it back.
Rated 5 out of 5 by SHESNTN The BEST Eyeliner on the Market
I can't understand the negative reviews. Apparently, this spectacular liner isn't being applied correctly or they purchased the wrong color. I wear this eyeliner every day & can't be without it. I have brown hair & blue eyes and wear either the Violet or Navy. It is awesome! You can apply it lightly or abit more if you prefer. I found that no matter how I apply it, it never fails me. It "is" bullet proof if you apply it correctly. I absolutely love this eyeliner & have used the most expensive to the drug store variety. This is the best there is--thank you Mally for a superb eyeliner. The violet & navy are staples for me, so please don't ever discontinue them. Thanks & happy shopping!
Rated 2 out of 5 by MISSY Q DISAPPOINTED
The way this was presented, it looked so nice. They do not go on with color. Yes they glide on but it does not stay on, like her other ones do. They are not waterproof. I will not buy this type again. I don't understand what I could have done wrong to get these poor results.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Linnielew Mally Eye pencils
I brought a five color eye liner set awhile ago. I absolutely love it. So I thought I'd order a new color. I love the smooth glide on feeling when you apply it. Very excited to check out the new color.
Rated 2 out of 5 by kpb10 barely there
Love mally! but not this product, dont waste your money or time ordering.. Its everything i hate about pencil liners. Its barely there, its almost like a waxy substance, barely see it. have to go over and over the lline to make it pop. awful. threw it away.
Rated 1 out of 5 by sohochic Dollar Store Quality
I look for Mally products and ordered this because of her product and the color. It doesn't roll up and there seems to be no product outside of the tip. The pencil container is such poor quality that the plastic started to break in my hand the first day of use and the only day before its breakage.
I do think I could find much better in the drugstore as this was so poor. Gladly, QVC will refund my postage for this defective item. I paid for an envelope so I still lost here.
Back to the drawing board, Mally. If I could give this no stars, I would.
Rated 1 out of 5 by silverthreads Not Bulletproof
I like Mally products but was disappointed with this. I have oily eyelids. Within 2 hours of applying this liner it is smeared on my lid looking like eye shadow. I tried using a primer on the lid and it did help but the liner still did not last the whole day.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Hard to fit Buy the ten pack. It is less expensive!
I decided to purchase these separately because they were advertised as .1 oz which is larger than the .01 oz of the ones in the ten pack. When I received these they were the same size as the ones in the ten pack. This resulted in me paying $85.00 for 4 pencils rather than the $50.00 for ten pencils. Customer service notified me that the advertised size of .1oz for the individual ones was a typo and that I could return the pencils for a full refund including shipping. Not happy about having to return but be aware that it is much cheaper to buy the ten pack even if you don't use all the colors.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Karakel Learning Curve But Love It
There is a slight learning curve to these such as not running these up too high. These are very soft and creamy when you apply them but given 60-90 seconds - boom. They dry. Not saying 100% bulletproof but enough to get me through a day of work. I only use these on the top though as I still haven't found anything better then another competing (store) brand for the lower that stays. I have people ask me where I got this or that color all the time! Love it!