Rated 4.1 out of 5 by 12
Rated 4 out of 5 by ZoieMae Great eyeliner, just constantly out of stock
I love Mally's liners, but when I need to order most of the shades are not available! Very frustrating! Please try to keep a better selection on hand. Thank you!
Rated 5 out of 5 by fata Best Eyeliner Ever
I love Mally's eyeliners. They go on effortlessly and do not tug on the delicate eye area and the solor remains until you take it off. The colors are not harsh, not even the black. There is a softness about the colors that compliment your face and make everything nicer looking. I even convinced my sister to try these eyeliners and now she is addicted as well.
Rated 3 out of 5 by djabr Love these..where are they? Colors sold out/gone!
Mally, how can we buy your products when they are not available??? I've been a customer for 10 years and love your eyeliners. My fav's are the unusual colors...black & brown can be bought anywhere. I have bought & repurchased many times your Caribbean Sea and Cobalt liners & shadow stick. Both are GONE. I have gotten more compliments wearing these 2 colors than any eyeliners, ever. Have been wearing eyeliner for decades. These colors brighten up my often tired eyes. If I want a deeper look, I just add a layer in another, darker shade. I am desperate to spend my money on your eyeliner. Please make it possible for me to do so. Maintain inventory, and keep in mind the diversity of your customer base! Also, that bulletproof cream foundation you made for years was really great -- and now it's gone too,. along with your cream blush. These 2, with your primer underneath, were fabulous. Are you changing just for the sake of change? Just because something is not new does not mean it's not a great product. Disappointed. Please remember the quality that made me and countless others Mally loyalists. Getting back to eyeliner, yours are (or have been) my go-to's for years. 5 star products for sure. I have given 3 stars based on disappointment & frustration about the inability to buy what I have come to love.Your business decisions are forcing me to look elsewhere -- and I don't want to!!!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by nitereader Great Eyeliner
This eyeliner truly goes on without any tugging. And it stays on. Please bring back the smokey taupe. Perfect color.
Rated 2 out of 5 by meme54 Smudges
This is supposed to be waterproof but I guess not smudge proof. I wore it for the first time and goes on great but at the end of the night it was under my eyes. This should not be happening and it needs to be relabeled.
Rated 4 out of 5 by CrystalMarie Very Nice
I really like it. Not as dark as I would like but flattering anyways. Goes on smooth and lasts doesn't smudge
Rated 5 out of 5 by Kryssi78 Great Product, Wrong Color
I gave this eyeliner 5 stars because it really is a good product, creamy to put on u dont have to struggle w it and is long lasting. My problem is that I ordered it ud ing the app on my phone , the color "wild thing" looked black or close to it. I received it and its dark brown.
Rated 4 out of 5 by lorhun great liner
I have had trouble finding an eyeliner other than liquid that stays put even for a few hours this does. Not exactly bullet proof in my opinion but lasts longer than any other I have tried. Love the midnight black and slate