Rated 4 out of 5 by 2
Rated 5 out of 5 by Crazy for Q Great Colors!
I ordered these because I liked the Smoky Quartz evercolor shadow stick extra I received in another Mally collection I purchased a few months ago. I does exactly what is promised. I don't purchase crème or stick eyeshadows because they always crease or diminish when I have used them in the past. Not these! They go on very smoothly, not dry and crumbly. The color is set 30 seconds after applying and STAYS that way until I remove it, sometimes more than 12 hrs. later. I'm not kidding, even when applied as a a lower lid liner! These are my new go to shadows & eyeliner. Thanks Mally! You are a genius when it comes to make-up.
Rated 3 out of 5 by pjhn22 Same as last year
This set is not new. I bought the exact same set last year. They all pull grey and taupy on me, even if certain ones look more brown when swatched on my hand. The only color that stands out is moonlight which makes a great inner corner highlight. I wish Mally would bring her old formula and colors back. I don't think these are bad but they are not as good as the old ones. I love Mally but I am not sure why the change in her super popular shadow sticks.