Rated 3.8 out of 5 by 12
Rated 4 out of 5 by DMS51 Stays on all night...
These eyeliners have staying power! I still prefer the original Mally pencil liners; but these gel waterproof liners go on smoothly -- and stay on.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Lynnestr STAYS PUT WITH HEAVY LIDS BETTER THAN OTHERS!
I have dark brow hair, medium brown eyes and heavy lids. This product stays put better than MAC and many others! It’s not perfect, but is about 90% better. I find I do have to take a public restroom paper towel and wipe the inside of my eyelid crease of traveled eye pencil every couple of hours, but it’s much better than having to do that every hour! And, with others, that meant that my eye pencil would slowly disappear during the work day. Not so with Mally. Most of it remains in place and that includes both upper and lower eye.
Also, with other eye pencils, I’d have to draw them on and go back and forth many times! Again, not so with Mally. I just draw it on once and maybe go over it a second time in the morning and I’m done!
I LOVE her idea of a lighter pencil on the lower lashes! Hello? Why am I just finding this out now? I was going to do that this morning, so I put on “Shadow” (dark metallic gray) on my lower lashes for the first time, and loved it so much, that I just went ahead and put it on my upper lashes instead of the black I had intended! LOVE “SHADOW” - and I really must have more colors! I’d REALLY like a medium green - in that same metallic look as “Shadow”! That color looks fantastic with my brown eyes! Plum is also good and I see that comes in her regular pencil duo, but I want it in the gel.
I recommend (although at the time I wrote this, it isn't available, but if they get it back in stock:
Gold & Silver Safekeeper Double-Sided Jewelry Armoire by Lori Greiner
(You can still look it up, though.)
Rated 2 out of 5 by caninecrazy NOT IMPRESSED
Wanted to try this because of eyeliner smearing and not lasting. Going through menopause so I get very hot. Was hoping this would last. It doesn't last much longer than the eyeliner I can buy at regular stores.
Rated 5 out of 5 by BevRM Great Eyeliner
Love the new gel eyeliners. I have small eyes, & they are easier for me to get a more perfect line. The brown is my favorite, as with her other eyeliners. I'm blonde, & the black is a little to much for me. Hope Mally will offer these in pairs, or singles at a later date in a variety of colors.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Dobes4Ever Best yet for gel liner :-)
Thank you Mally for another great product. I normally use LG's which have more colors to choose from and they are good, but don't glide on like yours and yours REALLY lasts all day. Thank you so much, more colors please!
Rated 5 out of 5 by cats7dogs1 Mally - great eyeliners
Like these. They stay put. I like the colors, soft neutral. Do not have to sharpen as with her others,but satisfied with those as well..
Rated 2 out of 5 by n225 Very Disappointed
First, 2 of them arrived broken. I tried the 3rd one to see if I would reorder. Small amount of product. I'll stick with the original Molly pencils.
Rated 5 out of 5 by lorenzleo Great!
I have always enjoyed Mally's eyeliners before and find these just as great, only in a gel form. Both are excellent!