A94113 - Mally Eye Performance 3-piece Collection
This 3 piece collection is nice. I have had the mascara and liner smear. Mine did not hold up to be bullet proof. I do like the creamy eye shadow.
This product set was wonderful! The products lasted all day and into the evening. I make sure that I apply an eyeshadow base before I apply the stick to avoid creasing. I do; however, apply this no matter what eyeshadow I apply. The liner is wonderful and it stays all day. I found that the trick is to keep it sharpened! The mascara is probably the best I have used. I really wish that this trio was still available!! What a shame!
I LUV MALLY...
...AND I LUV HER PRODUCTS! BUT TRYING TO SHARPEN THESE EYELINERS IS HORRIBLE.
These are amazing products and they work just like Mally said they would. I love them, they are all I use now. Thanks Mally and QVC!
I can't live without this set!! LOVE, LOVE, LOVE!!
I have purchased this set of 3 a few times now, and I LOVE IT!! I have also recommended it to my family and friends! Where do I begin with this review? I think I should begin with the eyeliner. It is creamy and precise and long-lasting! It is a beautiful shade which makes my eyes "POP". And then I add the Mally black mascara. WOW! It is long-lasting, easy to apply, and increasing my lash lengh beyond my expectations! Then I swish on my easy-to-apply, dimensional eye shadow stick across my eyes. This product, which was my "add on" item, adds depth and neutral color to my lids. I can't say enough about this set. The value is phenomenal. The products are strong, gorgeous and long-lasting!!!! I LOVE THIS SET!!!!!
I purchased this set a while back. I gave it 4 stars because the eyeliner really stays put more than any other I have ever purchased, however I wouldn't call it "bulletproof". It does come off and not only when you want it to. The mascara was a disappointment. Flakes off very easily. The eyeshadow is a lovely color but does shift into the crease of your eyelid. These products do perform better than others I've had, but they most certainly are not "bulletproof".
Not bad, but not as good as I hoped
I've been dying to try Mally's eye products. I finally did it. The mascara is amazing! It's everything she claims and more. Absolute BEST mascara EVER! The eyeliner was what I was really interested in and I am a little disappointed. It is better than most, but it is not "bulletproof". I do find that it smudges a little bit by the end of the day and it does not stay on the inner rim, as advertised. Again, it's not bad, I just don't feel that it lived up to it's claims. The eyeshadow stick is great. It is bulletproof. It doesn't budge until you take it off. Looks fresh all day.
worst eyeliner ever
This eyeliner was like using a huge magic marker on my eyes. The tip is way too thick...it just comes out as one big huge smudged mess. I decided to give it a chance but by noon I looked like I had been swimming the eyeliner was running down my face! I do not understand the hype. The eyeshadow was ok nothing special. The mascara is like any other mascara. I can't believe the eyeliner....horrible!
I absolutely love these products! The mascara is my favorite of the kit and I will definetly buy again.
with these products....no staying power....mascara did not meet expectations...eyeliner smudged...eyeshadow creased...
This is the second time I ordered this kit. This is my go to makeup for my everyday look. I really does go with everything I wear and makes my eyes pop!
No Staying Power
I have been on a quest to find the eye pencil that will last. Unforntunately this one doesn't do it either. Have some oily eyelids, have tried so many pencils. This one didn't even make it til 10 oclock and I use an eye primer. It glides right on but no staying power. The shadow is the same way. I guess I will have to stay with liquid liner. Mally's mascara is ok. Ended up giving this one to my daughter. I read the other reviews but this didn't do it for me.