Rated 3.1 out of 5 by 9
Rated 5 out of 5 by runner52 LOVE THIS EYE SHADOW BEST EVER
I ordered this eye shadow over and over again, this is the best! and stays on all day. If I don't take it off at night I wake up in the morning with it on and still look GORGEOUS!!
Rated 3 out of 5 by CharmedOne No longer bulletproof when layering colors
After having tried both old and new formulations of this product, I can confirm there is a difference in staying power. If I apply a crease color over a lighter base color, by the end of the work day the crease color has faded and is barely there. If I apply a crease color over a traditional powder eye shadow, the crease color lasts all day. I found that using a single color allowed for the bulletproof look we are all looking for, but layering the colors caused one or more of the colors to fade away as the day progressed. As I primarily use this product as an eyeliner, the fading when layered is not my major problem, but rather the lack of colors. Where are the greens? Five out of seven days I wear a green eyeliner. I no longer have that option with this product. Secondly, I love the pricing on the special 3, 5, & 8 packs, but want to select my own colors. Most sets have a few light colors which can not be used as an eyeliner.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Buzzylion The best!!
This is the best shadow I have ever found. No creasing.
one suggestion. color names are a bit misleading and the colors on the website, pretty much all look the same.
Need more colors like your old Firefly, a purple, blue, etc Not bright colors, but colors.
Rated 2 out of 5 by ZumbaMom Over The Taupe
This was my first time trying out Mally's Shadow Sticks Extra. I had swatched it before and it look very pretty and shiny.
However when I bought it and was able to really play with it, I found that when you blend it out, it goes matte, no shine at all. So it just wasn't right for me.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Egh why fix something that isn't broken
I agree with previous reviewers.... I REALLY liked the previous formulation better. Why would anyone change something that was already SO popular?
Additionally, it is VERY difficult to buy using the online color schematic because the labeled colors DO NOT MATCH the color that shows up on the screen.
Rated 2 out of 5 by pjhn22 Not as good as the original shadow sticks
I have so many of the old shadow sticks and they are great. These are not as pigmented and they all somehow pull taupey and grey on me. When swatched on my hand they look different but on my eyes they somehow look way too similar. I have tried multiple shades. The only one that looked different is the lightest shade and the blue shade. They need to go back to the old formula and get rid of these. I will not repurchase. I will use up what I have as a base for other shadows. I am about an nc15-20 coloring.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Just Me Too Previous version better
I have tried two shades and I am not happy with either shade. The previous colors were much nicer and stayed on better. I will have to find another brand. I am so disappointed because I loved the previous Evercolor Shadows.
Rated 3 out of 5 by peaceandlove NOT THE SAME as the fabulous, original eye sticks
I just loved and collected Mally's original eyecolor sticks; however, with the recent company change---these new versions are not the same. I have purchased several of these new silver case ones, and for me they skid upon application, feel drier, and don't last like her older bulletproof ones. Mally is the sweetest authentic person, but these sticks are not like the original ones.