A91864 - Laura Geller I-Care Waterproof Eyeliner Trio with Sharpener
Did Not Stay Put for Me...
The application is very easy but only the black is really visible -- the other colors are too light. I found that after a few hours the liner was essentially gone. I loved Laura's liquid eyeliner that came with the mascara on one end. Did not like the mascara but the eyeliner worked well for me. Wish we could have just the liquid eyeliner!
The black pencil was great
I tried these, not knowing only the black pencil was available in a duo. The black was great but the other two colors were too light. So I sent back and got Laura's black pencil duo. Now, I'm a happy camper. I hope Laura comes out with a black liquid eyeliner soon. For the reviews that were unhappy with the light colors, black is available, too, in a duo. I'll always be a "Laura Geller" girl!
Dry, Difficult to Apply
Could not get a line on my eyelid. The liners were dry and tugged on my eyelids.. When I got a line started it would stop and start and then I had to try to fill it in - usuallly unsuccessfully.
Not so waterproof..at least for me.
I must have very strange eye lids or something but I can NOT find a waterproof eyeliner for the life of me! These left a "second" line under my eye after a few hours. Maybe its not the product and its me...who knows. I did like the darkness of the black shade...however the purple and brown were way too light...and I fair/medium skin color. Sorry for the bad review...I really wanted to like these.
Not one of Laura's Best
Unfortunately I chose to return this product. At first I was thrilled because it was so easy to apply. However, it did not stay on and the tips of the eyeliner broke off very easily. I love most of Laura's products, but there is a problem with the mechanics and containers of a lot of them.
Liked The Black Only
I sent mine back. I liked the black liner, however, the plum was too light and the brown was too light. If the others had been a deeper color, I would have kept them. They did stay in place pretty well without smudging.
Dry and not suited for the eyelid or inner rim
T his particular product did not perform as seen on air. This set of eyeliners is so dry
that a pro could not rim an inner eye, line an upper or lower eye without causing drag to the eyelids without causing extra pull on this already delicate eye tissue.
The BEST ever!
I wear eyeliner everday and purchased these specifically because my eyes tear when the weather is cold and windy. I absolutely LOVE these eyeliners. The product glides on without tugging the eye area. It blends nicely with the blender tip. Plus you can sharpen them - which I find a treat in a mechanical pencil type liner. I love the brown and eggplant colors. I can't wear the black as it is way too dramatic and I am really fair. I definaltely will purchase more of this product in different colors.
I'm a Geller girl and rarely find a product of Laura's that I don't like. I do love these waterproof eyeliners. The eggplant one is a real treat because 1/4 of my closet is some shade of purple or berry. The black and brown ones are always useful. The best part about these eyeliners is that I can line part of my lower lid with them, and during the day they don't bleed out onto the skin below my lashes making me look like a raccoon. I can trust that her eyeliner will stay right where I put it. Thanks, Laura. Not only do I love how entertaining you are on your shows, but your products are fabulous.
Want stay on
Did not clean it off before bed and it was all under my eye the next morning.
I trusted her because I needed some new one.
Decided to give these a try, within an hour smeared all over. Thought they would be good for sticking in my purse or traveling with, but I got the same result with these as with other waterproof stick eyeliners. I'm sticking with the Bobbi Brown Gel liners, they area A little hard travel with or stick in my purse, but the only ones that have not smeared on me.
For most of my adult life, I've been seeking the perfect eyeliner. I have finally found it.
Laura Gellar, you are amazing and so is your eyeliner. Thank You!