Rated 3.5 out of 5 by 25
Rated 5 out of 5 by Victoria22 Favorite!
I love this palette, it is so pretty and I have been using it every day since I got it. I actually like to use it with my fingers instead of a brush and I love the looks I come up with. Every shade is perfect for me. I also really love the mascara, I have been using Josie's mascara for about a year and I have had no lash fall out or irritation or smudging with it. Perfect set! <3
Rated 2 out of 5 by ssmanx Mascara defective
Have only tried the eye pallette once and there may be possibilities there, but the mascara is dried out and clumply. Does not enhance the lashes is a positive way.
I am seriously considering returning the entire set because $40 is really too much for the eye shadow alone (with no applicators). Will try a few more times to determine final decision.
Rated 3 out of 5 by traceinmich mascara clumpy; eyeshadow pretty
What is going on with josie's mascaras? This is the 2nd time I tried and I am so disappointed. Maybe it is old. Maybe it's the formula. Maybe it's the wand. Let me know when u improve this mascara. I loved the original formula.
I see the origina mascaral with another kit...i wonder how old that is?
The eyeshadow is pretty and I'm on the fence if I'll keep.
We deserve better for this price. And we expect products to perform as u say they will.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Libbyie Disappointed
I wanted to love the mascara and I did for the first two uses, after that it went completely dry and clumpy. In less than one week in went into the trash can. For the price I paid it should have lasted much longer. The eye shadow palette is beautiful and does last throughout the day. I have many of Josie's products and have loved them all except the mascara. Sorry Josie!
Rated 5 out of 5 by CindyPindy Love it. My go to.
This pallet is versatile and is the most flattering for my eyes. I have Josie's coloring (Hair / Eyes) but am fairer. Can go soft or more dramatic, Always makes my eyes look bigger / brighter. Very beautiful colors. At first I thought the colors didn't really go on well, believe me, they do. Very happy with this purchase.
Rated 3 out of 5 by netski Okay
The eye shadow colors in this palate are great....love the colors but....didn't come with a brush or any kind of applicator. Too pricey not to. So I used my preference - a brush. Eye-shadow flakes as soon as brush touches it! Really JM! Too pricey for flaking! The mascara is fantastic!! Not so much the applicator. The brush is awful. Can't use it to apply on lower lashes. Have to use a different mascara on lower lashes and need to use a mascara comb/brush on upper lashes after applying. Love the mascara but not worth the trouble for the price. Hence the 3 stars. If better applicator AND price and available individually this would be my very most favorite mascara and would reorder. Too bad, so sad.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Stace808 Disappointed
I purchased this with high expectations after reading the reviews. Sorry Josie, but this isn't a home run. The colors are really pretty, but they were hard to apply. I found myself having to go back to the pallet over and over, just to get enough color on my lid. The staying power wasn't great either, by the end of the work day, the colors faded and looked like I had nothing on. As far as the mascara, the brush ruined it for me. I don't have long lashes to begin with so the brush was a little to big , for those with short lashes it was hard to get it to apply. I was looking forward to getting both these products, unfortunately they went back.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Rhonda in Ohio formula awesome, brush and packaging is a miss
I really like the formulas but the packaging is horrible, the eyeshadow does not come with a brush nor can you put one in the package, the shadow sits very oddly deep in the container, the mirror finish looks disgusting from finger prints. The Brush on the mascara is nothing short of HORRIBLE, impossible to get lower lashes without getting more product on my face, the big balls make it impossible for a clean application. If it was just the mascara I would maybe switch wands out with an old one but both are a miss for me.