Rated 3.4 out of 5 by 168
Rated 5 out of 5 by BettyB I'm Happy
I have a hard time finding mascara that works for me. This does a good job. This keeps my lashes curled up as most do not. With 2 coats they get longer to just the right length. Don't really care for the shape of the brush, but it gets the job done. DO like that it's good for my lashes. All in all, a good product.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Josie2014 Disappointed
I use Josie's oils and do like them. I was excited to get this mascara product, but found that it bleed every day. I tried to use it for two weeks and just got tired of cleaning up under my eyes a couple times a day. The mascara itself was globby, and the brush design was not helpful at all. It held too much of the mascara and globbed on. I did not return them, may try it again in a month or so. I won't buy them again, unless the brush applicator is changed and possibly the formula. Needs more work on this product.
Rated 5 out of 5 by PJ9923 WOW
This mascara is amazing. It's silky smooth, lasts all day, doesn't smear, feels great on my lashes and comes off easily with gentle mascara remover. I have been searching for a mascara like this for years. I can't wait to get it on auto-ship because I'm not planning to use anything else ever again!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Pamelaisme Love This Wonderful Mascara!!
Great Mascara!! It really lengthens & makes my lashes look longer & thicker!! And, it's Good for my thin lashes!! Love it!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by TERRI!!!! Great Mascara
Prior to trying this Mascara i was a die hard fan of another line for years. Then i liked so many of Josie's other products that i decided to try her mascara and now I'm hooked. I don't think she has a bad product.
Rated 5 out of 5 by rosierock Brought my lashes and eyes back to life!
My lashes have been thinning rapidly as I age. I had several areas that were completely gone and many areas that grew back in shorter. Last summer I started using the Black Oil mascara I discovered in a TSV. I noticed almost immediately there was a decrease in shedding. My lashes were growing stronger and filling in. I also love that I can sleep in it with no worries, so I'm waking up looking bright! I'll never be a teenager again but I've seen massive improvement using this mascara and don't want to be without. Josie, please please please, bring back The Black Oil Duo!
Rated 3 out of 5 by Jodi1 Not Good For Sensitivity
Made my eyelashes look great. However my eyes tear. Mascara then gets wet and leaves that "cat-eye" look.
Rated 5 out of 5 by emily64 Love!
I love this mascara! I had stopped being able to wear mascara because every brand I tried actually burned my eyes. I decided to try this product because it was natural and now I can wear mascara again! I also use the milk and argan oil to moisturize my skin--love them all!