Rated 3.1 out of 5 by 16
Rated 1 out of 5 by Flosey Not a good purchase at all.
I ordered the wrong size, however, the material was cheap. Did not like; returned
Rated 5 out of 5 by sportyspice Glad I Ordered
I like this shirt. The corduroy is a lightweight material but a tank can be worn underneath if you need more warmth. It does run smaller than some of my other Joan boyfriend shirts. I sized up after reading the previous reviews from and xxs to an xs. I am in between sizes so this 100% cotton shirt is tighter across the shoulders/back but not uncomfortable. The navy color is great. The shirt is cozy. After receiving I immediately ordered the grey as well.
Rated 2 out of 5 by 2005 not good corduroy
Returning. Med in all my other J R's shirts fit except the seersucker need lg. this med too small. Good Corduroy has a very fine hand & feels almost like thin velvet. This has a has a harsh feeling to it. And the cheap buttons goes without saying. I don't think Joan would have put up with this cheapness.
Rated 2 out of 5 by 1Sheila Really a Joan Shirt?
Like some of the other reviewers, This is not up to what I've become used to in Joan's Boyfriend shirts of which I have 6 in a 1x. The fit is just smaller all over like an inch or two so wouldn't be comfortable with a layered t shirt underneath. Also, I washed the shirt, Low heat dried about 15 minutes but it was so wrinkled still had to iron. It is not a high enough quality curdoroy for Joan's line that I have come to depend on. This is the first big shirt Of Joan's that I returned although I did like the rose color.
Rated 1 out of 5 by LilMilosMom If You Like Boxy...
This shirt does not have a flattering fit. If you are looking for an unstructured tailor-less fit you might like it.
Rated 3 out of 5 by corita not what I expected
i did not try this shirt on right away because it was still too warm here. But once I did, I did not like the fabric...very thin and weird. Almost a corduroy/velour mix...just too strange! Sending back!
Rated 3 out of 5 by wcpainter Petites Please
I am 5 feet tall. If only this shirt came in petite I would have kept it, but it just didn't look right on me. Joan has lots of "boyfriend" shirts, but as far as I know only one style comes in petite - it's denim and I have two of them. The petite sizing can make a lot of difference. Hey, QVC, maybe more petites would cut down on returns.
Rated 2 out of 5 by friscodisco poor quality
Disappointed in the material used in the shirts...very thin and the shirt is also too long for my liking
I did return the shirts and now question the quality coming from this brand.