Rated 3.5 out of 5 by 22
Rated 3 out of 5 by oyster Itchy-Scratchy
I was also disappointed in the quality of the cashmere. It is, as my title states-itchy and scratchy. I have many cashmere sweaters and all of them are softer than this. I purchased it in the emerald and it is a lovely shade. Also, I do love the cowl neck and I purchased in the XX Small, which is my preferred size and it is true to size. Now that it is on sale, I would not repurchase.
Rated 4 out of 5 by DestinTart COZY CASHMERE COMFORT!
I am 5'8" tall, a 40C bustline and wear department store size 14/16. After checking the online specific garment measurements, I ordered the Oatmeal in Large.
PROS: The same great Isaac Cashmere textile that is lightweight, elegant comfort. Beautiful oatmeal heather color. Fit is true; length as expected. Generous cowl that drapes nicely.
CONS: This style has a bit of a dolman sleeve, so there is extra fabric/fullness thru chest/armhole area. Not my preferred style for my bustline, but it is a beautiful sweater!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Shop Too Much Bought a Second One
I bought the magenta last year. It's soft and beautiful and the proportions are just right. Long enough but not tunic length, and a nice sized cowl neckline. I think the rolled edges give it a more modern look. When it went on sale, I snatched up a black one. I guess you either love it or you hate it. I loved it enough to buy a second one and probably should have purchased a third before the mediums sold out.
Rated 1 out of 5 by madshopper Not Up To Isaac's Standards
I have several of isaac's cashmere sweaters from last year and was very happy with them ..I purchased this sweater and his fringed shawl in oatmeal heather and both are on their way back to QVC .. IMO they were both itchy and not soft at all .. I was very disappointed in the quality of this cashmere.
Rated 2 out of 5 by mrdmrd looks like somebody has worn this
SWEATER TOO EXPENSIVE TO HAVE UNFINISHED EDGES ON SLEEVES,& THE NECK,TOO CHEAP, NOT WORTH HALF THE PRICE.
Rated 1 out of 5 by nycfifi Disappointed
I read some of the other reviews about the quality before purchasing, but decided to try it anyway. The other reviews were right. I have merino wool that is softer. I didn't even take the sweater out of the bag! Zipped it open, felt it and sealed it up again! As Shawn would say, it felt "itchy, scratchy." Isaac, darling, I'm sorry, you need a better supplier. Or better quality assurance.
Rated 1 out of 5 by rachlach Very Disappointed
This is not a soft as advertised. Only wore it about three times over this past winter and had it dry cleaned hoping it would soften it up....it didn't. This is way too expensive for the quality of the material. It was very itchy on my skin and doubtful I will ever wear it again. I have cheaper sweaters that wear better and are much softer, for less than half the price.
Rated 5 out of 5 by tvgifting Gorgeous Sweater
I am very happy with this purchase. I ordered two Black and Oatmeal Heather--gorgeous sweater-soft and cozy. I had many compliments when I wore these sweaters. I must admit I was not trilled with the rolled hems--but after wearing the sweaters, I found that I liked that feature. It is true when I opened the package I thought the sweaters were thin. I don't think this sweater would be so soft and cozy, and the cowl neck (love the cowl neck can be positioned any direction!!) would lay so perfect, if otherwise!!! The size I ordered was small it was a tad too big--but I like a roomy sweater. The ones I purchased are just grand!! Love them would buy another sweater if offered in "RED"????!!!!