Rated 4 out of 5 by 158
Rated 3 out of 5 by Nicole71 It's a good idean in theory, but...
I've wanted to try this product for a long time and I ordered this because it's a great deal. However, I would not recommend this for contact wearers. The product flakes halfway through the day (or at least it did on me, maybe I have a bad batch) and I found flakes around my eyes for two days afterward, even though I clean off my eyes and mascara daily with a makeup remover. The flakes got into my eyes as well, which is uncomfortable as Hades when wearing contacts. I am giving this product a 3 star rating because the idea is good, the brush is good, and it does create a tightline effect as promised, but the formulation is bad.
Rated 2 out of 5 by LJP62 Not So Crazy About Tightline
It is easy to apply, but the tube has very little product in it and it tends to get very messy at the top of the tube. I would not buy this product again.
Rated 5 out of 5 by RedRockMom Great Lash Definition
I am a very particular person when it comes to Mascaras. I have very straight lashes that are resistant to curling...good length though. Frequently I would curl and put the mascara on....straightens out. Found if I heated the eyelash curler, curled and applied mascara...was better. Then i found out that there were Volumizing mascaras! That helped make a difference. I found for me the cheaper mascaras worked better for my situation BUT I decided to try the Tightline and was so impressed. Great definition and held the curled lashes in place. I have tried some top prestige brands but IT beats them all and no smearing. I love the mascara and highly recommend it! Love so many of the IT line!
Rated 5 out of 5 by fsufan45 Highlights Eylashes
I love the way this product's brush can find the fine eyelashes you didn't know you had-separates lashes and the mascara is not too thick!
Rated 1 out of 5 by TJOC Worst ever
I was excited to get this home and it was part of a TSV. I have poor lashes that are stick straight and not to my eyebrow in length. It was so dry I wasn't even sure there was any product in the tube. When I did get it to work, it was flacky and did not cling to the base of my lashes. I'm glad I got it in a TSV and didn't have to pay full price for it. Really disappointed.
Rated 5 out of 5 by kbshopping Awesome to use as a Primer for my favorite Mascara
Does a great job defining lashes, I like to lengthen with another mascara after I separating with this one. It really does reach the faintest lashes an adds a fullness that is impressive. I have tried a ton of mascaras and I like the small brush because you can get up close without making a mess under the lower lashes and on the lids. This mascara reduces the time I spend trying to apply to my inner and outer lashes. Thumbs up on this one...
Rated 5 out of 5 by Kimberly17 IT Cosmetics Tightline mascara
Love this mascara!! It gets every single lash. I wish it came in Dark Brown color as well!! Please make Dark Brown too!!
Rated 1 out of 5 by gingergirl1 Smears badly
I was so excited about this product - until hours after applying it and going about my business at the office, I looked in the restroom mirror and was horrified that I had big black smears under both eyes. It was like getting magic marker off too. I am beyond embarrassed - I looked like a crazy old lady with too much makeup on. Horrible.