Rated 3 out of 5 by 13
Rated 1 out of 5 by Nancy Fancy Pants Dried Out
I received this eyeliner in a sample size as part of a Beauty Sampler. It is the only one of the six products that I was interested in. I was sorely disappointed to see it break off every time I tried. I am not an experienced eyeliner woman and have very sensitive eyes. Love other IT products, but this one is just plain bad.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Jen6 Love it!
For me, best liner ever! Glides on effortlessly, easy to use. I put it on at 6:30am, and by the time I take it off around 11pm, it's still on! I have not had a problem with it drying out or breakage.
Rated 3 out of 5 by grammy2000 It's OK but not Great
Ordered the grey/navy combo and the navy looks black. I double checked by writing on paper it is black. Not worth returning but I won't purchase again. Don't see any more benefit than drug store gel eyeliners and about the same price. I haven't had the drying problem I'm reading about. THAT would have made me return.
Rated 1 out of 5 by trophy wife NO! NO!
Have lots of IT products but I ordered the gel eyeliner and it was totally dried out and would not even mark on paper! Months later, I tried it again in a kit. Same thing. Plus, so many people have made the same comment on the kit, that you would think IT Cosmetics would discontinue the product and offer a replacement. However, they just continue to market it. Don't know if it is the formula or verrry old products.
Rated 1 out of 5 by angbe breaking eye liner
I bought this product hoping it will be waterproof and it was. It did not smudge or budge.
My problem was the constant breaking of the pencil eyeliner. It broke and fell out of tube. Did not sharpen well if just kept snapping. Not worth the value.
Rated 2 out of 5 by 44Shopper These No-Tug Liners,TUG
I've had these liners before and Loved them. This order I received are not the same, they tug and do not go on very well. I hope it was just a bad batch because I really liked the first ones I got.
Rated 2 out of 5 by mickeymom Dried Out
I bought the brown and black and after a while the liners became hard and difficult to apply. I had to throw them away. They were good at first and had staying power, but I'm disappointed they didn't last longer. I will not purchase the eyeliner again.( I will stick with the CC cream from this line because it's amazing.)
Rated 2 out of 5 by yma Cannot sharpen
I received the eyeliner and was able to make a very narrow line on my top lashes. It came with a pointed tip. Once the tip was gone there is no way to sharpen the liner therefore I cannot make a narrow line. Is there something I am missing? Would not buy again!!!