Rated 3.3 out of 5 by 20
Rated 1 out of 5 by Belle840 Not worth the purchase at all!
I first tried it cosmetics with sample I got from Ulta. I then decided to purchase several products on QVC as they were on easy pay. This was one of the products. At first I loved it. About a month into using it I noticed it started drying out. After 2 months I couldn't even get anything out of the pot because it was completely dry. I am always very careful with makeup and to close it tightly so it's not exposed more than it should be. This is was awful and was very surprised because all other It Cosmetics products are amazing but this was definitely not part of their greatness. Honestly I know there are a lot pf mixed reviews on here but don't waste your money on this.
Rated 2 out of 5 by patbar61 First thought but then......
If I would have written this the first week I used it I would have given it 5 stars. When it was about half gone it started gumming up and impossible to apply. I am a cancer patient and the meds I take make my eyes water excessively so I have to use a waterproof liner. Not sure where I'll go for the next purchase.
Rated 2 out of 5 by howiknow Disappointed
I loved this product the first few times I used it. Knowing it was a gel, everytime I dipped into it, I would put lid on so it would not dry out. But it did. Didn't get to use half of it. Thought I had a great product but not worthy of re-order. Sorry!
Rated 2 out of 5 by LynneM Dried Out
I bought 2 of these eyeliners and was very happy with the colors and quantity ... but ... the second time I went to use one of them it was completely dried out. To bad it's too late to return it. I'll stick with Bobbi Brown, smaller amount but they don't dry out.
Rated 3 out of 5 by hottoshop Why does it dry out so fast?
I love the product and it STAYS PUT for sure...but why does it dry out so quickly? I wear liner every day to work and on the weekends and I barely made a dent in mine before it started to dry out. At least 3/4 of the jar is unusable. That's a big disappointment :-(
Rated 2 out of 5 by 4Julz2 wouldn't recommend
beautiful color, gel liner becomes dry Goby no longer creamy and Smooth to apply. Disappointed
Rated 5 out of 5 by Scarlett811 Best eye liner ever
I got this in plum and coming back for more colors. It goes on like a dream stays on and the purple is spectacular. I highly recommend
Rated 1 out of 5 by Peemz Driest eyeliner ever
This started out great, but did not last more than a month. EXTREMELY DRY and impossible to use for more than a few weeks. Get with it, It Cosmetics - many other people are also saying this about your eyeliner. IT IS DRY DRY DRY.