Rated 2.9 out of 5 by 13
Rated 4 out of 5 by GirlfromPA Very Stylish Top
Despite other negative reviews, I really like this top, but giving it 4 stars because of price (I paid original price). It fits true to size (I take XXS, 5'7", 118 lbs), and is very elegant, especially in the black. I usually don't like crazy asymmetrical hems, but this one is just perfect, longer in back and front for a very classic, sleek look. Given the slender, more form-fitting style, the top is best with a pant that has no front zipper closure which might cause a bulge. So, not really for jeans, but great with leggings/jeggings or wide leg pants that are smooth at the waist. I haven't been tempted with much of GILI since Lisa left, but this is one of the nicest tops that GILI has ever done. I may go back for the blue or olive.
Rated 5 out of 5 by candy High End Quality
I own a lot of logo I find to be made quite thin and flimsy. This has substance. I ordered small very pleased with this purchase. I am a 36dd and wear size 6 Jean 140 lbs. The small fits well. Highly recommend...love it
Rated 4 out of 5 by Pink4270 Wish I hadn't Listen to Review
I ordered this tank top in x-large because of a review stating how small it ran and that you needed to size up at least 2 sizes. Well when I received them (I order 2) they were too large and I should have just ordered my regular size in the GILI brand. So now these have to go back and hopefully they have my size in stock. I am a petite gal and have a hard time finding things that fit my proportions... these do... and I really like the fabric and style.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Erics Mom Not Happy
I read the other reviews and thought how bad can the material be so i ordered them. Well, they are going back. The material is very poor quality and not worth the price. I really wanted to like these because i liked the style. Sadly they are going back.
Rated 5 out of 5 by paulette r Good Quality Tank Buy Your Brick And Mortar Size
I don't understand the negative reviews. This is a heavier rayon span. It is nicely made and good material for a layering tank. Lori Goldstein's tanks are much lighter weight and usually in the same or a higher price range. I wear a pp in brick and mortar stores in this type of tank (fitted). This Gili tank fits like my brick and mortar size, form fitted ... Spot on. Xxs in typical QVC sizing has relaxed fit on me. If you mainly shop at QVC size up. This tank will be better on hourglass shapes. If you carry your weight in the trunk another style might be more flattering.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Nana Russell The price Including S&H not worth It.
Says it's high end, quality looks very cheap. Runs very small for the price. Should sell 4 for the price of one.
Rated 1 out of 5 by witchblade175 Lacks Quality
Purchased this top as I like the peplum style and thought it looked great in a tank version. Although the style idea is great, the material is not. It feels, looks, and hangs as a stretchy cheap material. Not worth the price at all. I love GILI. But they missed on this one.
Rated 2 out of 5 by NJGIRL Runs very small
I received this top in green, extra small. I always wear size xxs but thought I would be fine with xs since it is fitted. The xs was extremely tight and I would need a size small to fit. So be aware that this top is skin tight & runs 2 sizes smaller than I usually wear. I am 5"7 and weigh 100 lbs. I think it is overpriced.