Rated 4.2 out of 5 by 12
Rated 2 out of 5 by delete Very Nice But Not Waterproof.
Received these items, they did have a somewhat perfect line, but they did not stay in place, they were not run proof
Rated 5 out of 5 by Jeffer Best Eyeliner Ever!!!!
No need to look anywhere else. This eyeliner glides on perfectly every time. I have tried many and none compare. Love!
Rated 5 out of 5 by naleah Best I have found
Has not irritated my eyes and does not smear when I use eye drop for dry eyes.
Rated 3 out of 5 by bronwen12 Stayed, but smeared
I am on the hunt for an eyeliner that stays all day, especially on the waterline. This stayed as well as anything on the upper lash line, but I found that it also smeared below my eyes by mid-day (and I didn't put any under my eyes). Other products stay as long on upper lashes and don't smear, so I'm returning.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Lizzy68 The Best!!
Love everything about these! Please don't ever stop making this product.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Nic67 The BEST eyeliner EVER!!
Does not smear, smudge, travel down or irritate eyes. Goes on smooth and effortlessly. I love, love, love! Ordering more sets! Can't be without.
Rated 4 out of 5 by cosmicquality Simply the Bess
Ok, I have tried all types of eyeliners from drugstore to high end. This gets top marks for staying power and for being able to deposit color by the waterline that stays. I have excellent staying power as long as the rest of my makeup routine remains the same, witch means all products used in my eye area such as primer, eye cream are oil free and I use my makeup setting spray. I get more color payoff in the under the lower lash area than any liner I have used previously. I had to take off a star because I would like a little more creamy in the formula (my usual faves are Urban Decay and Charolotte Tilbury) and I love the fact that I do not have to sharpen this liner, but I do not get as fine a point as I do with the pencils that I sharpen. Beyond my wildest dreams would be if I could use this with Bobbi Brown basic eye cream and and Edward Bess Flawless Illusion foundation under my eyes. I love Edward's FI foundation but I can not put it right under my eyes. I can only use Laura Geller French Vanilla as a concealer. I have a very short list of mascaras that do not smudge on me I am early 50"s, high cheekbones, deep set eyes that are becoming hooded. I love the drama of the black, but I would love this in a grey or navy. I like the style of black on upper lid and a color on the bottom. This does the trick of covering redness under my eyes from allergies, does not make my eyes water and I love the smudge tip.
Rated 5 out of 5 by New Mexico Sharon Best eyeliner ever
This is the best eyeliner I have ever used over the past 50 years. The color stays. I could use the eyeliner on the inner eye lid and it did not make my eyes water nor did the color fade or disappear. Wish the eyeliner was offered in a softer color as well for the aging face.