Rated 3.8 out of 5 by 209
Rated 5 out of 5 by RRLL BEST NO SMUDGE NO SMEAR
OMG where has this eyeliner been all
I've tried EVERY water proof, smudge proof eyeliner from pencil to gel to liquid. In a pot, in a pen, in a whatever!
This is the FIRST eyeliner that doesn't smudge in my outer corners! EVER! I cried at a funeral and IT DIDN'T RUN!!!! I use a drugstore oil based makeup remover and it comes right off! EASILY! How hard is it to grab a cotton swab and dip in a bottle and wipe??
I Love this liner
Rated 5 out of 5 by garden25 Best ever!
These pencils are long wearing to be sure! I absolutely love them!
Rated 1 out of 5 by jovie Does not stay on
Does not glide on at all, pulls the kids because it's so dry. Wears off fast, and I even put a primer on. Very disappointed.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Josie2014 Love this liner
I thought I would try another eyeliner. I have tried many. These eyeliners are great. Not to soft and not too hard, easy to sharpen and apply. They don't break off when you sharpen them. The colors are great and very muted, but look great. This was my first Doll 10 purchase. Going to try other products.
Rated 1 out of 5 by she-she01 No No and No
This product did not work as presented. Very dissatisfied!! Really Doll?
Rated 5 out of 5 by silkys Great For Mature Women
I love these liners and I will tell you why.......for us over 50 women who still wear makeup, and still want to look good without looking like a clown, these glide over the lids in great colors.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Megan84 Not a fan
I really wanted to love these however the purple was completely dried out when I received it. The other pencils were smooth like butter when applying. By the end of the day the eyeliner had run slightly beneath my eyes. I am 30 years old and wear makeup all of the time. These might work for many people but they just were not for me.
Rated 4 out of 5 by summer1102 Good staying power
I have tried almost every liner on the market and these have great staying power and ease of use. My only criticism is the violet is not violet colored at all. It is a very dark plum black color.