Rated 2.3 out of 5 by 3
Rated 1 out of 5 by Qcumber Tasteless
I received a large box of these as a gift. I was very happy to receive these as I had no time to bake my own. Neither one of my teenage sons nor my husband and I liked them. Pretty tasteless and frosting is very sweet.Really poor quality ingredients. They sat around so long we had to toss them! When asked if I liked them by the gifter I said of course. Next year I received another box!!! Threw them out again. Not one package did we open.
QVC I thought you chose better quality.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Cofins4Terorists Bought 2 boxes when was on special
I am happy I didn't pay full price for these. The raves during the airing are the reason I purchased 2 boxes. Very large family so wanted enough for all to try at our big family gathering. They DID arrive on time however very few of us cared for them:
I will say the Lemon and the Strawberry went over very well.
The Chocolate Chips? Only so so.
The Blueberry Muffin cookie? Well some really liked and others said nope.
That Cherry and Chocolate cookie...ALL agreed could barely taste any cherry and what we did taste were hard. Primary taste is chocolate. ALL were disappointed.
That Iced Butter Cream, the youngest kids did eat these, the adults that tried them said no.
Those Malt cookies...As a true malt lover was disappointed in this cookie as quite frankly couldn't taste that malt.
The inner packaging needs to be rethought since there is nothing to keep those cookies from bouncing around in shipment. Perhaps a bit of bubble wrap between the cookies and the lid? Far too many were broken. Remember UPS tosses the boxes, in fact of the items I received on that same day both cookie boxes looked as if tossed onto porch.
The fact so many were broken allowed us all to try the various flavors though.
Would I ever order from this company again? I doubt it unless I read here a great many good reviews. Sorry QVC these weren't worth the sale price and most certainly not the full price.
Rated 5 out of 5 by ms-ikey Treat for college students
These cookies were delivered to the dormitory very quickly and were so well received that I got a PHONE CALL (not a text!) immediately. I am not the mom who sends treats every month -- but these were too good to pass up. The kids loved them (21 year old boys/men).
Thank you Cheryl's for making me the cool mom this week!