Rated 3.7 out of 5 by 13
Rated 3 out of 5 by hialtitudeangel Beautiful Fabric and Design, Just not for my shape
I got all three colors, and thought they were absolutely beautiful. But, I am a few pounds overweight, kind of an apple shape right now I guess, and it just didn't work for me. I think on the right shape it would be just lovely, floaty and graceful and a bit boho-chic. I wish so much that they had worked--I love Bob's designs, and have quite a few. Also, the shoulder was odd on me--one lady remarked maybe this isn't for bustier gals--but the neck and shoulder just looked wrong on me--very round, and not defined. They are a great weight, not see-through, and would be cool and nice for spring and summer. A smaller size might have worked, but I found another top that really works better for me right now, and think I'll go for that. Anyway, if you are slender, this could be perfect for you if you love something colorful and arty.
Rated 5 out of 5 by diamondamongrhinestones What's not to love??!!
I mean this sweetly when I rhetorically ask: How can one not love this top??!! Actually, I have some ideas regarding what may have gone wrong. Firstly, this top runs slightly large. I looked at the measurements specific to the garment and consequently chose an xxs. Fits perfectly. I have two other tops from Mr. Mackie's collection, and they are both an xs, which leads me to conclude this one runs large. Secondly, perhaps some have difficulty choosing colors that flatter their appearance. I'm a fair-skinned, green-eyed, highlighted brunette, and I chose the grey combo. (As an aside, the grey combo top matches wonderfully with black, grey or off white bottoms, which lends to its versatility.) Thirdly, if you don't like to be noticed, don't buy this top. Mr. Mackie is known for his artistic and dramatic designs--um, he is well-known for styling Cher and Diana Ross, so again with a nice tone I say that should give you a clue! Anyway, the fit, color, and design are lovely. Finally, for those who love it, but are concerned about the ruching losing its elasticity, keep in mind that the item description does say "hand wash." I think as long as you don't use hot water, and line dry, there won't be a problem. I sense that heat is what ruins elastic.
Rated 1 out of 5 by chasmo Good luck with this one.....
I tried the shirt on and the appearance was certainly questionable. I showed it to my husband and he burst into laughter. I asked him if it looked ok and he asked if I was joking. He said it was the ugliest shirt he'd ever seen and thought I looked like a cupcake. I had a suspicion that it looked strange, but he confirmed it. It was bad!
Rated 5 out of 5 by SeMjAmBAM VIBRANT!!!
LOOKS LIKE A CHOIR ROBE BUT IT IS ACTUALLY VERY PRETTY!!! I GOT THE ORANGE AND YELLOW COMBINATION OF COLORS IT GOES WELL WITH MY COMPLEXION!!!
Rated 3 out of 5 by QVQT Just OK
Ordered the grey version, size M, and liked the print, but not on me. It "fit" (as in another size would be too big or too small) but I guess I'm a little too "round" or well-endowed for this style. I think it would be great on a more slender person with squarer shoulders.
Rated 5 out of 5 by missy111 I Love This Top!!
I bought all three colors. I wore the grey combo with a black maxi skirt and received compliments on how lovely it was. I washed all three in the machine on the hand wash setting and they came out beautiful. No wrinkles. I did not place them in the dryer. I am very happy with this purchase.
Rated 1 out of 5 by 1027 Awful
I agree with other review. Do not buy this top. Sizing and fit awful. .
Print, awful. Do not buy. I should get my shipping money back.
Rated 1 out of 5 by RandiLisa Awful
This top was awful. It looked like I was wearing a potato sack. It had absolutely no style whatsoever and was huge on me. For those who loved it I'm jealous! The colors were pretty :)
Rated 5 out of 5 by EHG Loved it!
Bought the Grey/Lavendar/Pink/White combo. Got several compliments the first time wearing it out. Reminded me of something I owned in the 70's
Rated 4 out of 5 by tootsie8 True to size
Very comfortable and received compliments with the first wearing . Wish it was machine washable . But love all of Bob Mackies designs in clothes. Not to sure about the neckline becoming looser as you wear it?
Rated 5 out of 5 by PhillyPam Fabulous
This is a gorgeous top! Very dramatic, and I was going to return because I didn't quite know what to do with it. Pulled it off the shoulder, and hubby gave it 2 thumbs up and suggested wearing it to an upcoming dinner party and to the theater. I ordered the purple option, and it looks great with black palazzo pants, skinny leg cropped pants, and a straighter maxi skirt. Stunning!my usual QVC size was perfect.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sage333 Love it, love it, love it!
It is much better in person and I dearly LOVE the fact you can wear it off the shoulder, just the way I like it!! Ordered all three, I hope Mr. Mackie's does some different fabrics, in this same style. I'm 5'9" and looks great with capris, it is just wonderful!!! Tons of compliments!!