Rated 3.6 out of 5 by 41
Rated 3 out of 5 by Lainer66 Very Large
I ordered a size XL. I am 5'4'', 195# evenly proportioned hourglass figure. This item has a very nice print and is a soft, substantial, fabric.
It is definitely a simple poncho and will need something under it. I think it is very cute, but it runs very big. The neck opening is very large. The sleeves do not have any arm attachments. I am thinking it may be challenging to keep it in place, given the poncho style and the slick fabric. Maybe a cotton long-sleeved shirt under it would do the trick.
I would consider reordering in a smaller size but some of the other things I ordered I like better and I have enough things now. I will return.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Growerswife Runs Really Big
This runs really big. It's a lot of material and is very heavy. I returned it.
Rated 5 out of 5 by pqm love this top so many complements
This is the first item i have ordered from Renee. I love it and received so many complements. It is different and comfortable
Rated 2 out of 5 by careerwoman A rare miss for Renee
I am a big fan of the Attitudes by Renee line, and I have loved all the pieces I've purchased...until this one. I really wanted to love it. The print and color are pretty, but the dolman sleeves fit strangely, and they don't tell you that you need to wear a tank or cami under this. Just wasn't for me.
Rated 5 out of 5 by britnits Gorgeous And Flowy!
I don't understand the negative reviews of this item- I mean it is a poncho, albeit with sleeves, but still a poncho. Of course it's going to be oversized and flowy and drape. That's what it's supposed to do. I am in love with it and have been receiving compliments all day. I wear off of one shoulder and ordered my true size. The print is stunning, I think I will order in red and navy now too!
Rated 5 out of 5 by missb314 Can't Wait to Wear
I had this top on my wish list for a while. So glad that I finally got it. Sleeves are a bit fitted but love the unique styling. Nice fabric. Does require a top underneath. Runs large. I normally wear a small top in this brand but ordered XS and it fits great.
Rated 2 out of 5 by linkhigh Might be the oddest garment I've ever tried on
I bought this top on clearance because I thought the fabric was gorgeous. It was! That's where the good news ends.
Based on the reviews, I purchased one size smaller than my normal QVC size. In spite of this, the top is still too large. The neck, in particular, is huge. I would constantly need to be readjusting it to keep it centered on my body and keep bra straps covered. The sleeves, on the other hand, are almost, but not quite, skin tight. The "shoulder seam", which actually hits halfway down the upper arm, is a ridge of fabric that I would constantly be aware of, and wishing I could make it go away. Annoying in the same way as an itchy tag at the back of the neck.
For me to wear this, I would have to put a turtleneck sweater underneath, and then the sleeves would really be too tight.
I pondered if there would be any way to alter it (like cutting off the sleeves?), but in the end, I decided it just wasn't worth the effort.
Oh, and the final straw was when I showed my husband, and all he said was, "Please don't". I don't defer to his opinion in everything, but in this case, he was right.
Rated 4 out of 5 by KMH16 Unique
I was on the fence about this top when I put it on. You do have to wear a cami or tank underneath it. I wore it and got good comments. I also posted it on my Instagram and got a lot of likes. It's very comfortable and I got the blue so it goes with denim and slacks.