Rated 3.8 out of 5 by 32
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sweetbay magnolia Gets Better With Each Washing
This is comfortable and much better than a slouchy sweatshirt. Reminds me of an artist's smock. The pockets are handy for "stuff", and for keeping the hands warm - and you can almost wrap yourself up with them without the garment clinging. Very cozy. I love the 3/4 length sleeves, because I like to layer underneath with a long sleeve and it allows that to show. The two lengths don't compete. The ruching makes it look pretty, even without a layering piece and then it is nice for bracelets. Each wash males them more soft and comfy, like they are a "favorite" in the wardrobe. I have five and I like them better all the time. Wonderful with Susan's Printed Feather Weave Button Front Shirt (see my recommendations). 5'5", 133, M. The top is generous in size but intended that way.
Rated 5 out of 5 by AuntyM Just ordered #5
I love these tunics, which are heavier weight than normal french terry, more like a sweat shirt. They are warm and comfortable and hide all my "extras." They wash great and machine dry too. LOVE THEM!!
Rated 1 out of 5 by kulagal Disappointed in product condition
I've had luck with As Is products in the past but this time I received a top that had been treated with a sickly sweet deodorant. It was also pilled and stained. After numerous washing's and soakings (white vinegar helped the most), the odor is just now becoming almost tolerable. It's still strong though. I may have to discard it.. I love these tops. I have them in 6 different colors. I won't ever take the chance of buying As Is again. It's not worth incurring postage fees (both ways) to return a discounted item.
Rated 2 out of 5 by 4bauers Almost A Hit...
The chest area was too tight and the waist/stomach area was huge. Strange, normally does not happen with the Graver line. Back it goes. Nice comfortable fabric thou.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Botticelli29 Stained
I have purchased several "as is" items in the past from the Q without any problems. However, this shirt came with a dark stain right on the front. I was very disappointed and couldn't justify keeping it even at the $30 price tag. I did like the fit and style of the shirt but I agree with other reviewers that said the full $50 price tag is too much. It is a cute and fancy fitting sweatshirt that would look good with leggings. If they have the "as is" in a size and color you like then give it a shot but don't get your hopes up because I am not so sure the quality control is there.
Rated 3 out of 5 by jansam Good, and bad
I purchased this top in my usual size - medium and it was HUGE! I then purchased it in small - still too big. I went to XS and it was too tight in the arms and across the bust. I am 5"4", 135#s and a 34D. I loved the material and the idea of a sweatshirt that was flared at the hem. Did not give up - found that the sizing is inconsistent and now I have kept 2 size small shirts - in black and berry and love them both. They wash very well and look great. For the "as is" price, they are great but I would definitely size down one size and avoid it completely if you have a large bust size.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Q Fan 2 Too long
I am returning this "as is" top because it is too long and too much fabric for my short, stocky body.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Jersey Girl22 Too Big!
This would be a cute top but there is way too much material in the back. Looks great from the front but look at yourself in the mirror from the side and it's all wrong! Back it goes.